Tag: #law

The environment assumes a vital part in human existence as well as in the advancement of society. With developing mechanical progression and industrialization, the immaculateness of the climate has been threatened to a horrifying degree. The need to secure and further develop the climate is so convincing for the endurance of humankind and other life structures on planet Earth that the right to climate has arisen as basic liberty. Climate alludes to the regular environmental factors and conditions where we reside. Tragically, the environment has gone under genuine danger. This danger is for the most part because of human practices. These human exercises have absolutely made genuine harm to the environment. Most significant, this harm takes a chance with the endurance of living things on Earth. Subsequently, there is a pressing need to save the Environment.

For this, environment security is improving, guarding, and keeping up with the nature of the climate. The fundamental strategies for natural assurance are reusing, reusing, and lessening; be that as it may, a few different techniques like Green Energy creation, green transportation improvement, and eco-accommodating industrialization likewise exist. Inhabitants, as well as organizations and ventures, should assume their essential parts to work on the climate.

HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS

Mankind has forever been worried about the climate. The antiquated Greeks were quick to foster a natural way of thinking, and they were trailed by other significant human advancements like India and China. In later times, the worry for the climate has expanded due to developing consciousness of the biological emergency. The Club of Rome, a research organization, was quick to caution the world with regards to the risks of overpopulation and contamination in its report “The Limits to Growth” (1972).

The advanced ecological development started during the 1960s when worries about the adverse consequence of people on the climate started to increment. Because of these worries, legislatures all over the world started to pass regulations to safeguard the climate. In the United States, for instance, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) was laid out in 1970.

The start of ‘present day’ global ecological regulation is dated 5 June 1972 which denotes the start of the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment in Stockholm. This period incorporates numerous advancements that occurred up until the 1992 United Nations Conference on Environment and Development.

STOCKHOLM CONFERENCE

It was in 1972 when interestingly nations across the world met up to distinguish and resolve natural issues at the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment in Stockholm. This occasion has had an enduring impact on the improvement of global ecological regulation. This gathering depended on the focal issue of contention between the financial turn of events and ecological insurance and it was this meeting where the idea of Sustainable Development was molded. The gathering was gone before by the Founex Meet in Switzerland where it was perceived that natural insurance and monetary improvement should go connected at the hip accordingly establishing a framework for the idea of feasible turn of events, which legislatures affirmed later at the Rio Conference on Environment and Development. At the Stockholm Conference, the Stockholm Declaration on the Human Environment was taken on which prompted further improvement of worldwide natural regulation. Because of the Stockholm Conference, nations laid out the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) in Nairobi, Kenya which was not laid out as a United Nations specific organization.

A few significant multilateral arrangements related to the Stockholm Conference, are the Convention for the Prevention of Marine Pollution by Dumping of Wastes and Other Matters and the Convention for the Protection of World Cultural and Natural Heritage, in 1972, and the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) in 1973. These arrangements were the early support points of global ecological regulation and along with the UN Conference, set up for the improvements in worldwide natural regulation.

In the following twenty years, global natural arrangements multiplied and in excess of 1100 worldwide legitimate instruments that were in without a doubt committed to the climate. In this period, nations became skillful at haggling new arrangements in brief periods which didn’t surpass 2 months.

The global natural arrangements went into during this period began as a means of observing and revealing explicit ecological dangers and had its own, discrete office to help nations in executing the concurrence with independent conventions for the exchange of peaceful accords, including trans-limit air contamination ozone environment, and so on the time frame between 1972-1992 saw changes in the subjects and the focal point of global ecological arrangements. The extent of arrangements additionally extended from controlling trans-limit contamination to worldwide contamination issues, for example, the consumption of the ozone layer, monitoring environments, and so on.

HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAW IN INDIA

In the course of the most recent twenty years, the Indian judiciary has cultivated a broad and inventive way to deal with environmental rights in the country. Complex matters of ecological administration have been settled and therefore a progression of inventive procedural solutions have advanced to go with this new meaningful right. The new environmental right is subsequently advocated as a legitimate pathway to expedient and modest lawful solutions.

The notional development of the right to life was perceived even without any particular reference to the infringement of this major right. However, the basic liberty culture has permeated down to the Indian human rights system within a short time frame. An interdisciplinary way to deal with environmental protection might be one more justification for the activity of the right to a healthy and clean climate. This has been attempted through global ecological agreements and shows, public administrative measures, and judicial reactions.

It has been studied in the case of environmental laws and policies, the Indian scenario is actually filled with attempts and examples in trying to preserve the environment from further degradation. Let’s look into how that protection came into being by going back to the historical background. Ancient India had always been keen and concerned in maintaining protecting the environment. But let’s look into how the British’s then passed legal regulations and actions carried out as it is what has had a huge impact on how India has turned out to be in the present age.

During the British Period, they looted India off of their natural resources, combined with a total indifference with regards to environmental protection. An overall overview of early natural resource regulation uncovers that separated from the wood’s regulations, nineteenth-century regulation likewise somewhat directed two different parts of Indian climate- water contamination and wildlife. These regulations, in any case, had a restricted reason and restricted spread in other regions. Obviously authoritative measures were taken by the British Government for fighting against contamination and for the preservation of natural resources. In spite of the fact that pundits call attention to that the British authorized these regulations, not with the object of safeguarding the climate but rather fully intending on procuring income for themselves, it ought to be viewed as the initial move towards the preservation of natural resources. Regardless of the way that these actions were made with ulterior intentions, British-sanctioned regulations have contributed essentially to the development of environmental jurisprudence in India.

Some of the laws passed during the British rule are,

• Merchant Shipping Act of 1858 dealt with the prevention of sea pollution by oil.
• Shore Nuisance (Bombay and Kolaba) Act, 1853 imposed restrictions on the fouling of seawater.
• The Fisheries Act, 1897
• Wild Birds and Animals Protection Act, 1912
• The Bengal Smoke Nuisance Act of 1905
• Bombay Smoke Nuisance Act of 1912

And after Independence,

• The Indian Constitution embraced in 1950 didn’t manage the subject of climate or counteraction and control of contamination all things considered.
• It was the Stockholm Declaration of 1972 that turned the consideration of the Indian Government to consider environmental protection.
• Exhaustive (exceptional) ecological regulations were established by the Central Government in India.
• Public Council for Environmental Policy and Planning was set up in 1972 which was subsequently developed into the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) in 1985.
• The Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, focused on the objective and present-day wildlife management, and many more.

ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS AND POLICIES IN PRESENT INDIA

Prominently, the public authority has passed different regulations to check the harm caused to the climate, for example, the Environmental Protection Act, 1986, Forest Conservation Act, 1980, Water Prevention and Control of Pollution Act, of 1974, Public Liability Insurance Act of 1889, Biological Diversity Act of 2002, and National Green Tribunal Act of 2010.

As indicated by Article 48 (A) of the Indian Constitution, the state will attempt to safeguard and work on the climate. It ought to likewise attempt to defend woodlands and the natural life of the country. As per Article 51(A) (g) of the Indian Constitution, each resident of India has a basic obligation to safeguard and further develop the indigenous habitat including backwoods, lakes, waterways, and untamed life and ought to have empathy for living animals. These are some of the rights among others like sections 253, 246, etc.

Now let’s get into how these regulations tend to have a fallback or poor implementation. One of the primary explanations behind this is that there is no autonomous administrative body for ecological administration. It is taken care of by the Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MoEF). Because of inordinate obstruction by the government on the administration of the Ministry, there is unfortunate execution of natural regulation. The politicians also lack the willingness to further push the need for effective implementation, adding on with the lack of awareness of the people.

Businesses are committed to taking authorization from the State Pollution Control Board to release effluents and cause outflows yet there is laxity in consistence because of the absence of solid punishment measures. The Comptroller and Auditor General in India in its 2011-12 report on Performance Audit of Water Pollution in India say that the punishments for the contradiction of WPCA 1974 are excessively frail. There is also a lack of funds for the Pollution Control Boards and they don’t even have proper infrastructure or laboratories. These are just some of the problems amongst many in India. And to correct these few, the following solutions are recommended. A free administrative body should be laid out. The MoEF in 2009 had proposed for a “Public Environmental Protection Authority” in its discussion paper which would go probably as a body for ‘noticing, rule, and execution’ of natural administration. Like on account of Vellore Citizen Forum versus Association of India the guideline of polluter pay rule was applied. For this situation, a Public Interest Litigation was recorded by the candidates in light of the fact that the tanneries and different enterprises were releasing untreated effluents into the River Palar in Tamil Nadu. 35,000 hectares of the farming area has become either absolutely or somewhat ill-suited for development as per Tamil Nadu Agricultural University Research Center, it was held that the enterprises need to pay the townspeople for the harm brought about by them and furthermore make up for the rebuilding of the environment.

Public awareness and an increase in the political will to help is an absolute necessity. NGOs can assume a vital part in this. Prizes should be given to businesses, associations, and so on to recognize infringement and make a move to resolve the issue. Financial endowments, cost-sharing ought to likewise be advanced. And many other steps should be taken like giving more funds to SPCP.

Actions to protect the environment are also taken by the people themselves. Many climate/environment-oriented actions have been initiated which is indeed commendable. Some of the notable movements have taken the forms of advertisements, protests, like the recent protest which was staged by the All Assam Students’ Union (AASU) and All Assam Matak Youth Students’ Union against the decision made by the National Board of Wildlife (NBWL) to allow North-Eastern Coal Fields (NEC) to do opencast mining in 98.59 hectares of Dehing-Patkai Wildlife Sanctuary in 2020, to protect the wildlife sanctuary and the vast fauna. Or the SAVE AARAY movement in 2019, mobilized by the people to go against the Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Limited’s (MMRLC) metro 3 car-shed plan that would lead to the felling of the Aarey Colony, and the only national park that was situated outskirts the metropolis, rich in flora and fauna. This was also done to protest against the fact that many tribal communities had also been displaced by big project plans.

CONCLUSION

So, therefore, the Stockholm Conference definitely assumed a critical part in illuminating ecological corruption that has been caused around the world. Thus, the worldwide level of natural and biological issues has been improved to a particular level which the nations of the world had never envisioned ever.

The Courts in India have played a distinctive job in step by step broadening the extent of a good standard of living by applying different issues of ecological protection. Therefore, practices representing a significant danger to the climate were diminished to safeguard the person’s human right to a healthy climate. Article 21 has been dependent in plenty of cases, albeit certain cases have consolidated a more extensive point of view of the Constitution.

With contamination expanding every year and causing the crumbling of the natural habitat, it has become important to find ways to safeguard the common habitat. As we realize that the justification for this multitude of issues is people, state-run administrations should decide to limit their exercises that are actually hurting the climate. And if they are not halted direly, then, at that point, the world could see some devastating collapse and degradation before it’s too long. For instance, environmental change has been a huge issue, and this is one of the reasons for continued contamination. A good future relies upon the climate in general.

Written by Tingjin Marak, a student at Ajeenkya DY Patil University, Pune.

ABSTRACT

The given article seeks to explore the evolution of the Arbitration laws in the Indian sub context from stem to stern. The article traces the journey of Arbitration from the enactment of the very first legislative piece in 1899 until the most recent amendment of 2019.

INTRODUCTION

In order to decipher the insightful journey of the arbitration laws, it shall be necessary to first comprehend the meaning of the term ‘arbitration’. Colloquially speaking, the term ‘arbitration’ basically means an adjudication of disputes by an impartial and independent third party i.e. arbitrator. Thus, arbitration is a private, out of the court procedure. Regular court procedures are usually complex, expensive, and time-consuming. Adjudication of the disputes via the less formal and alternate forums such as the ‘arbitration’ provides a more effective and speedy resolution of disputes.

Thus, Arbitration is the result of written agreements between the parties wherein the parties agree to submit the accruing present or future disputes arising out of a legal relationship between them to an arbitrator.

ARBITRATION PRACTICE IN THE ANCIENT WORLD

The practice of arbitration has been pervasive throughout the world since ancient times. King Solomon of the ancient Jewish empire is usually hailed as one of the first arbitrators as per the Old Testament. The book by Elkouri and Elkouri¹ describes in length the arbitration proceedings of Solomon that bear resemblance to the modern-day arbitration practice. Further, the Greece historian Homer also gave detailed accounts of arbitration in his poem wherein the third party adjudicators settled the disputes between the masses.

In the Indian subcontinent, mentions of arbitration can be found in ancient texts of Brhadaranayaka Upanishads² that mentioned about srenis, kulas, pugas, and other autonomous bodies which adjudicated arbitration proceedings. Instances of local adjudication of disputes without the intervention of courts via the panchayats can also be found in Mauryan and Mughal times. Even today, the Khap panchayats are examples of such extra-judicial bodies that arbitrate disputes among the parties involved.

SCOPE OF THE LEGISLATIVE ENACTMENTS

1. THE INDIAN ARBITRATION ACT 1899
The said Act³ came into force on 1 st July 1899 and was drawn on the lines of the English Arbitration Act. It was the first legal attempt to formalize and codify the laws and procedures pertaining to the arena of arbitration by filling in the void created due to the absence of legislative enactments. The Act sought to amend and facilitate the process of Arbitration by agreement between the parties which therein gave away the need for engaging in the long-drawn tedious and complex procedures of the civil laws. However, the applicability of the Act was limited only to the presidency towns of Madras, Bombay, and Calcutta.

The Act provided that if the parties explicitly agreed in writing to refer to an arbitrator in the event of any dispute, then in the event of an eruption of any dispute, an application could be made to the court, having jurisdiction in the said matter, to enforce the arbitration agreement, the subject matter of which should be legal off course, in accordance with the provisions of the agreement and appoint an arbitrator, in absence of any agreed provision for appointment of any specific arbitrator between the parties thereto.

The Act lays down in length and breadth about the ifs and nots for appointment of an arbitrator, procedure for the perusal of the evidence, grounds of mistake for setting aside an arbitration award, powers of the court to enact arbitration agreement, enforcement of arbitration award, stay of proceedings, award of the decree, and a host of other provisions.

The scope of Arbitration further got modified and codified with the enactment of CPC in 1908 under Clause 1 to 16 of Schedule II, whereby the provisions of arbitration were extended to the other parts of India. However, the infancy of the Indian Arbitration Act with its inborn imprudence coupled with the technicalities of the CPC 1908 proved to be incapable of governing the catena of arbitration and thus paved the way for the enactment of The Arbitration Act 1940.

2. THE ARBITRATION ACT 1940
The act⁴ provided systematic and comprehensive legislation on arbitration by improving upon the shortcomings of the previous Act. It came into force on 1 st July 1940 and extended to the entire Indian territory except for the State of Jammu and Kashmir. The Act sought to amend, bolster and integrate laws relating to arbitration and provide for a hassle-free arbitration experience, thereby saving the precious time of civil courts.

The Act provided for agreement between the parties thereto for the appointment of an arbitrator by a third party and; the appointment of up to three arbitrators by the parties themselves. The appointment of an arbitrator could be revoked only by the leave of the court and further, the death of the parties did not discharge the arbitration agreement. The Act widened the horizon of the court by empowering it to appoint, modify or remove the arbitrators; or modify/ remit the arbitration award after its filing in the court, if it deemed it to be fit. The Act also imbibed the provisions for insolvency of the parties, powers of the arbitrator to grant interim awards, powers, and procedure of civil courts, etc. It is to be noted that the Act was subservient to the provisions of the Indian Limitation Act 1908.

The major flaw of the Act was that it only dealt with adjudication of domestic arbitration rewards and had no imbibed provision for the enforcement of foreign awards. Further, ineffective application of the provisions of the Act, leading to irregular and faulty proceedings gave a major blow to the applicability and usefulness of the Act. In the case of Guru Nanak Foundation v Rattan Singh⁵, the Supreme Court lamented over the inefficacious working of the Act which had led to time-consuming and complex procedural claptraps.

Despite the inherent malaise in the applicability of the act, combined with other infirmities, the act remained operational until the year 1995. The economic liberalization policy of the 1990s necessitated the creation of a favorable and conducive business environment so as to attract investments and provide speedy dispute resolutions, thereby enhancing the ease of business. Now, in order to simplify the tedious and complex court procedures and facilitate the businesses, arbitration as a method for commercial dispute resolution was encouraged and it was in this background that the Arbitration and the Conciliation Act 1996 was passed by the parliament.

3. THE ARBITRATION AND THE CONCILIATION ACT 1996
The act⁶ came into force on 25th January 1996 and repealed the Arbitration Act 1940. The Act was enacted in consideration to and in consonance with the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration.

The Act provides for domestic as well the foreign commercial arbitration coupled with the enforcement of the international awards. The Act for the first time carved out an avenue for the process of conciliation. The Act is divided into four parts, spanning 87 Sections. Part 1 provides for the procedural details of domestic arbitration and Part 2 provides for enforcement of certain foreign awards in the light of New York and Geneva conventions while Part 3 deals with the aspect of Conciliation by elucidating it in length and breadth.

In the case of Bhatia International v. Bulk Trading S.A. and Another⁷, it was held that the arbitration benches seated outside India shall be subjected to Part 1 of the 1996 Act unless it was impliedly or expressly excluded.

The Act gives paramount importance to the autonomy of parties which can be adduced by the expressions used in the Act such as “with the agreement of the parties” every now and then. The Act underpins the necessity of the arbitration agreements for enforcement of arbitration proceedings, gives full autonomy to the arbitration tribunal to carve out the procedures, and seeks to clearly distinguish between arbitration and conciliation. Moreover, the Act intends to provide for speedy resolutions which could be deduced from the fact that it did not provide a second appeal except for an appeal to the SC.

In the case of Centrotrade Minerals and Metals Inc. v. Hindustan Copper Ltd⁸, the court underpinned the fair and impartial adjudication process of the arbitration tribunals that gave paramount consideration to the party autonomy and safeguards therein. However, the court criticized the cumbersome procedure for setting aside the arbitration awards.

Given the beneficiary aspect of the said Act, it suffered from the twin malady of excessive court intervention and procedural expensiveness. Challenge of an Arbitral award under Section 34 of the Act would put an automatic stay on the execution of an award thus, making it executable. Also, a charge of excessive fees by the arbitrators and absence of time limit for adjudication of the arbitration award would make the option of arbitration altogether as a means for dispute resolution unfeasible and cumbersome.

This necessitated the needful improvisations in the said act and hence the Arbitration and Conciliation Amendment Act was passed in 2015, incorporating the required amendments.

4. THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION AMENDMENT ACT 2015
The act⁹ came into force on 23 rd October 2015 and sought to amend and consolidate the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996. The Act amended Section 2(1), 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 14, 17, 23, 24, 25, 28, 29, 31, 34, 36, 37, 47, 48, 56, and 57, and furthermore, added a fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh schedule to the principal Act. The key features of the amended Act are as follows:

• The Act added to the meaning and interpretation of the term “courts” with respect to domestic and international arbitration. As regards domestic arbitration, the term ‘court’ shall include both principal civil courts in districts and High Courts in the exercise of their original jurisdiction and with regards to international arbitration, the term ‘court’ shall include only High Courts in the exercise of their original civil jurisdiction.
• International commercial arbitrations whose benches are seated outside India shall also be subject to the provisions of 9, 27, and 37 of the Act, and the ensuing arbitral reward of such cases shall be perfectly enforceable in India.
• As regards interim protection awarded by the courts, the arbitration proceedings shall commence within a period of 90 days or if any as determined by the court, from the date of order for grant of interim protection.
• In order to curb the unnecessary court interventions and uphold the spirit of the arbitration agreement, the act makes it necessary to refer the subject matter disputes to arbitration in case of the existence of arbitration agreements for such matters.
• The Act seeks to curb the discretionary power of CJI and bring to the center stage, the twin institutions of the Supreme Court and High Courts instead of keeping CJI and his nominated institutions at the forefront for the task of appointing arbitrators.
• The Act confers power upon the central government to amend the fourth schedule.
• In order to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of the process of arbitration, the Act prescribes a period of 12 months for the completion of the arbitration proceedings under the Act and also accordingly awards the arbitrators for speedy dispute resolutions.
• To encourage transparency, impartiality, and fairness of the entire scheme of arbitration proceedings, the Act prescribes for disclosure of any past/present or direct/ indirect relationship of the arbitrator with parties thereto or subject matter of the dispute that may give rise to justifiable doubts as regards to impartiality and independence of the proceedings. The fifth schedule of the Act extensively and methodically lists out the cases of arbitrator’s relationship with parties thereto that are likely to vitiate independence and fairness of the proceedings.
• The Act provides a scope for the appointment of guardians during the course of arbitration proceedings for minors or for persons of unsound mind.
• The Act seeks to encourage to the greatest extent, the scheme for oral hearings. Moreover, the Act drives to foster the virtue of regularity as regards the arbitration proceedings and dissuades adjournments by levying heavy costs.
• The Act equips the arbitrators/ courts with discretion to determine and award the costs to be paid by the parties to each other and to the arbitrators/ courts per se.
• The Act uncovers speculations by defining the conditions that lead to a conflict of public policy in India. The conditions include the cases of fraud and contravention of Indian law and notions of morality or justice.

The case of Perkins Eastman Architects DPC and Ors. vs. HSCC (India) Ltd.¹⁰ dealt with the unilateral appointment of the arbitrators, wherein the two judges bench of SC held that a person who was ineligible to act as an arbitrator cannot appoint one of his choices and the court could exercise its power under the Section11(6) of the Arbitration Act 1996 and appoint an independent arbitrator to maintain fairness and impartiality of the proceedings.

In spite of the much-sought amendments brought in by the Amendment Act of 2015, the lack of institutionalized arbitration mechanism was deep-rooted in the country. In order to perpetuate the institutionalization of systematic arbitration, an ad-hoc committee headed by Justice B.N Srikrishna was constituted. On the lines of proposed improvements suggested by the committee, the Arbitration and Conciliation Amendment Act 2019 was enacted.

5. THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION AMENDMENT ACT 2019
The amendment Act of 2019¹¹ came into force on 9th August 2019. The act seeks to amend Section 2, 11, 17, 23, 29A, 34, 37, 42 43, 45, 50, and 86 of the Principal Act. The Act further adjoins the eighth schedule and part 1A to the Act. The salient features of the Act are as follows:

• The act seeks to ease out the responsibility of the already overburdened HCs and SC by provisioning the addition of arbitral institutions for presiding over the process of arbitration which shall be accordingly designated by the SC and respective HCs, thereby ensuring speedy disposal of the disputes. In the absence of designation of arbitral institutions by the HCs, the CJ of the concerned High Court shall appoint a panel of arbitrators for the purpose of discharging the said functions of arbitral institutions.
• The arbitral institutions so constituted shall have the authority to adjudicate the cases of international arbitration.
• In order to expedite the process of admittance of claims and defenses during the course of arbitration proceedings and encourage speedy disposal of cases, the act provides for completion of the above-said claims and defenses within a period of six months from the appointment of arbitrators.
• The Act curbs the extraneous application of other laws as regards appeal under this Act and provides for only those appeals that are listed and validated by Section 37 of the Act.
• The Act absolves the liability of the arbitrators from those impugned actions that are done in good faith.
• In order to boost the competency of the arbitrators, the act prescribes minimum qualifications for the appointment of the arbitrators which shall ultimately lead to the excellence of the arbitration mechanism.
• The showstopper of the amended Act is the establishment of the Arbitration council of India that will seek to regulate the niche practice of Arbitration and Conciliation in India and make the country, a booming hub for inexpensive, effective, and sought after hub for the process of arbitration. Part 1A inserted via the amendment Act of 2019, describes in length about the constitution, functioning, and governance of the Arbitration Council of India.

CONCLUSION

The practice of arbitration as means for the settlement of commercial disputes has been a popular tool. Being speedy, cost-effective, and efficient, it provides viable options for the resolution of disputes that would otherwise take tremendous time, cost, and effort of the parties involved under regular civil litigation. The legislative enactments in the field of arbitration underwent major amendments since 1899 in order to keep abreast with the latest developments. The recent amendment of 2015 and 2019 took leap-bound steps to inculcate practices that would encourage transparency, independence, and impartiality of the arbitration proceedings, thereby preventing unnecessary intervention of the courts and ensuring speedy and timebound disposal of the cases.

References:

1. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/216936738.pdf
2. http://csjournals.com/IJITKM/PDF%2010-2/21.%20Sumit.pdf
3. http://jkarchives.nic.in/Record_Holdings_PDF/Acc.%20No.%201149.pdf
4. https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1052228/
5. (1981) 4 SCC 634
6. https://legislative.gov.in/sites/default/files/A1996-26.pdf
7. (2002) 4 SCC 105
8. 2006 11 scc 245
9. https://lawmin.gov.in/sites/default/files/ArbitrationandConciliation.pdf
10. SC/1628/2019
11. https://egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2019/210414.pdf

Written by Riya Ganguly student at Bharati Vidyapeeth New Law College, Pune.

Introduction

Over time, many changes occur in society; these changes have both beneficial and harmful consequences. As the nature of law evolves, new laws and amendments are introduced into society to regulate the violation of living beings’ rights, privacy, and security.

There’s a Bible proverb that goes something like this: “Either you can believe all of it or you can’t trust any of it,” and that’s how fake news spreads. If you can’t distinguish which news is real vs phony, which is truth vs lies, many people will quickly throw up their hands and declare that none of them can be trusted.

With the introduction of computers, the internet, social media, and networking websites, these developments, particularly on the technological front, became mass development with the introduction of computers, the internet, social media, and networking websites, which crept into and made their way into people’s lives.¹

The law of social changes as trends change. People are discovering new ways to conduct crimes in a high-tech manner as time progresses. However, by adopting new statutes and enactments, the law has broadened its jurisdiction and begun to remove these flaws from society. As a result, the Government of India has submitted a bill called the Fake News (Prohibition) Bill, 2019.

Fake News Prohibition Bill, 2019

The Fake News (Prohibition) Bill of 2019 was passed to make it illegal to create and distribute fake news in the media, as well as other related issues. In India, fake news refers to misinformation or disinformation conveyed by word of mouth and conventional media, as well as more recently through digital modes of communication such as altered videos, memes, unconfirmed adverts, and rumors circulated on social media. This statute applies to the entire country of India, it includes:

a) Misquotation of one’s remark is an example of fake news.
b) Altering audio and video files, causing facts and context to be distorted.
c) For the advantage of a person, agency, or entity.

Objectives of the Bill

Fake news has made it easier to spread false information in the era of the internet, where anybody can submit a report or a comment that appears to be a news item and declare it to be accurate and factual. Fake news or information must display or intend to exhibit propaganda to blacken or disgrace one’s reputation or create or plan to induce fear, division, turmoil, violence, or hate. Due to the propagation of fake news on social media platforms such as Whatsapp, Facebook, and Twitter, a huge number of mob lynching occurrences have been recorded around the country. Political parties were also discovered to be distributing misinformation on social media during the country’s elections, according to studies.

To control and the spread of fake news in any form, whether it is through circulation, sharing, misquotation of statements, editing of audio and video clips, fabricating content, undermining, sowing seeds of enmity, sedition, hatred, disseminate, edit, abet, etc., a debate took place in the House of Lok Sabha on the subject on February 8, 2019, and Shri. Tej Pratap Singh from Mainpuri proposed before the Hon’ble Chairperson to introduce The Indian media research organization CMS indicated in a report by The Guardian that the growth of false news was due to India’s “lack of (a) media strategy for verification.” Additionally, reporters and journalists have been imprisoned for “making false stories, “particularly when the pieces were contentious.

Fake News in India

In Alakh Alok Srivastava v. Union of India², the Supreme Court of India acknowledged the problem of infodemics in India and issued an order for state governments to follow the Centre’s orders to combat the threat of fake news. The top court also highlighted the necessity for the government of India to provide a daily bulletin through all media outlets as a source of real-time verifiable information on Covid-19 to alleviate the fear and apprehension generated by the uncontrolled flow of fake news.

The recent mass evacuation of migrant workers was caused, according to this petition, by the anxiety induced in the minds of the laborers as a result of bogus news that inflated the duration of the lockdown to endure for more than three months. Poor migrant laborers were killed as a result of this evacuation, which was brought about by the distribution of illicit information.

Fake news spread over WhatsApp in Odisha, claiming that a person from outside the state had been sick. After an inquiry, the police discovered that the claim was untrue. At the time, India lacks a specialized law to control false news; yet the epidemic is demonstrating the necessity for one.

Provisions of different laws in India

Information Technology Act, 2008 (IT Act)
In India, social media platforms that are classified as ‘intermediaries’ under Section 79(2)(c) of the Information Technology Act, 2008 are obligated to exercise due diligence when performing their tasks. Initially, under the Act and the April 2011 guidelines, intermediaries were not liable if they were not responsible for the origination, transmission, or reception of such content across their reach. As a result of this change, intermediaries gained protection, allowing them to be slackers in their efforts to combat bogus news.

When the government realized its error, it devised a remedy on the opposite extreme of the spectrum, instructing intermediaries to proactively block information. These restrictions have been compared to censorship in China. The government can use this as a political weapon to suppress stuff that does not benefit them. The free expression would be harmed by such a law.

Indian Penal Code (IPC)³
Section 505(1)(b) of the IPC deals with the dissemination of false and malicious material that causes fear or panic in the general public, or in any segment of the general public, with the intent of inducing an individual to commit an offense against the state or public peace. The offender under this section can be punished with imprisonment of a maximum of 6 years and a fine. Section 505(1)(b) combined with Section 54 of the DMA have been envisaged to include the expansion of fake news to a large extent.

The actual issue with fake news is fraudulent information that is disguised as real news in the form of unpaid pieces. The malice requirement might be avoided, and the spreader of misleading information could face severe responsibility and exemplary damages. The implementation of strict responsibility, on the other hand, would need tracking the disinformation back to its source, which has been recognized as a time-consuming and inefficient procedure.

Disaster Management Act, 2005 (DMA)⁴
Section 54 of the DMA professes to handle ‘false alarm or warning as to disaster or its severity or magnitude, leading to panic’ and this has been applied while recording arrests so far. It makes the offense punishable with imprisonment up to 1 year and the imposition of a fine. The same provision, on the other hand, has long been criticized for being too narrowly focused on catastrophes at a time when the breadth of false news is far broader.

While this one-of-a-kind characteristic of the Act restricts its use to disasters, it does have a good side effect. It ensures that the use of this clause does not extend beyond the extraordinary circumstances of a disaster, preventing the government from using it to further restrict free expression.

Curbing Fake News within Jurisprudence

Restriction of some rights can be permissible in the context of major public health hazards and public emergencies endangering the nation’s survival, according to international human rights law. The size and severity of the Covid-19 epidemic have elevated it to the status of public health danger, justifying limits on freedom of expression and speech. Such limits, however, must adhere to the standards of international human rights law. The same has been enshrined under Article 19(3) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)⁵ which requires the limitations to have a legal basis, to be solely significant, to be subject to review, and to be proportionate to acquire the aim. While it is vital to take steps to prevent the spread of disinformation, there is an unintended consequence. Efforts to combat false news might result in the imposition of censorship laws or the suppression of critical thinking that is essential to make educated judgments. To combat the spread of disinformation, Thailand’s government recently enacted restrictions that included a blanket prohibition on communications that are either “false” or “misleading”. The Thai government used this method to detain an artist who challenged the government’s reaction to the current public health crisis.

Concluding Observations

During this situation, it is critical to combat bogus news. It should not, however, come at the price of free expression. Temporary measures that take away some liberties in the near term but do not turn out to be a political weapon for any ruling administration are the way ahead in suppressing free expression. Temporary measures will allow the government to make necessary modifications to the current system to safeguard us. We should allow the government to protect us in our weak state, but this should not result in the government abusing our frailty. To combat the rapid spread of fake news, the government must collaborate with the public and intermediaries. We must do so; else, fake news may prove to be as deadly as the epidemic. Without a question, the problem of fake news and fake is growing like wildfire around the globe, necessitating the passage of legislation to regulate and restrict the transmission of fake news on social media and other platforms. The bill was constructed and prepared with the goal of prohibiting the transmission and distribution of false news, and thus “The Fake News (Prohibition) Bill, 2019” was created and presented to the Lok Sabha.

References:

1. Critical analysis of the Fake News (Prohibition) Bill, 2019, by Yogesh V Nayyar, Advocate in Supreme court. https://blog.ipleaders.in/critical-analysis-fake-news-prohibition-bill-2019/
2. ALAKH ALOK SRIVASTAVA v. UNION OF INDIA, Supreme Court Of India, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 76 Of 2018 | 01-05-2018 https://indiankanoon.org/doc/129422211/
3. THE INDIAN PENAL CODE, 1860 ACT NO. 45 OF 1860 1* [6th October 1860.]
4. Disaster Management Act (DMA), Power to remove difficulties. [23rd December 2005.] https://www.ndmindia.nic.in/images/The%20Disaster%20Management%20Act,%202005.pdf
5. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, United Nations, Treaty Series, vol. 999, p. 171 https://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6b3aa0.html

Written by Hemant Bohra student at School of Law, Lovely Professional University, Punjab.

About Innoventory Solution:

INNOVENTORY SOLUTIONS is an Independent Patent & Technology Consulting Firm with a focus on innovation to its successful commercialization. We strive to stay centered to align everything with clients’ end objectives and offer a unique blend of innovation technical and Patent expertise to enable independent handling of complex matters.

Pls read more about Innoventory Solutions at https://innoventorysolutions.com/

Duties and Responsibilities

Legal & technical perspective field experience required. Have to work as a unit in the company and should bring creativity to draft a patent.

Skills and competencies

For drafting a patent from a technical approach and should have well-versed knowledge in the ethical process for the patents.

Have some experience in the IPR field. A well-informed person who sits with the team and works on the ideas to draft a patent.

Relationship :

Should be working effectively and efficiently in the company with the group.

Aiming to maintain healthy relationships with

the co-employees.

Perks

1. Working closely with notable law firms

2. Invaluable guidance from budding lawyers and professionals

3. Exposure to legal, strategic, and operational learnings

4. A letter of recommendation

5. Certificate of performance

If you are someone seeking pivotal growth in your learning curve and want to validate your judicial learnings, get in touch today.

Contact Information

info@innoventorysolutions.com

(+91) 9877428600

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

For regular updates we can catchup at-

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

About IOCL

IndianOil, a diversified, integrated energy major with a presence in almost all the streams of oil, gas, petrochemicals and alternative energy sources; a world of high-calibre people, state-of-the-art technologies and cutting-edge R&D; a world of best practices, quality-consciousness and transparency; and a world where energy in all its forms is tapped most responsibly and delivered to the consumers most affordably.

Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. has been featuring year after year among India’s Best Companies to Work For and has been recognized as Best Employer among Nation-Builders. Recording an all-time high Profit After Tax of Rs. 21,836 Crore in FY 2020-21, the organisation is propelled to perfection by its high-calibre people adopting best practices aided by state-of-the-art technologies, cutting-edge R&D. To fuel its future growth, Indian Oil is looking for experienced, energetic and dedicated Law Officers with bright academic record and rich experience to join the Organization as Senior Manager (Law) [Grade – ‘D’; Pay Scale: Rs.90000 – 240000]

Detailed eligibility criteria in respect of prescribed educational qualification, age, experience, application procedureshortlisting methodology etc.is in the pdf attached below:

Senior Manager (Law) [Grade – ‘D’; Pay Scale: Rs.90000 – 240000]

Deadline

31st Dec 2021

Application Link

https://ioclapply.com/Home.aspx

Contact us

recruit2021@indianoil.in

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still, it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

For regular updates we can catchup at-

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

Themes

▪︎Research and analysis of the history of sports law in UN Current development of Sports in Un System

▪︎Olympism and Human Rights

▪︎The World of Sports and Politics

▪︎UN on Sports for development of peace UN Securities and Sports Development

▪ UN on Safeguarding Sports from Corruption

▪︎UN against doping in Sports

▪︎UN and IOC: the never-ending Bond

▪ UN on Sports and the Sustainable Development Goals

▪︎Sports and UN’s Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities

▪ International Treaty and Sports Sports as Anti – Terrorism weapon used by UN

▪︎UN Transgender Policies for Athletics Programs The role of the UN and the significance of the Paralympics in today’s world.

Editors:

Mr. Subhrajit Chanda Asst. Lecturer, JGLS

Mr. Tarun

Asst. Prof. (Research), GNLU

Mr. Pranav Yadav

Mr. Nishant Sheokhand Asst. Dean, Asst. Prof., IFIM Bangalore

Asst. Director FICCI-Sports and Youth Affairs

Details

Download brochure for full details

For regular updates, join us:

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

Intake Analyst, Law – Litigation at Ocwen

Location: Bangalore, KA, India

Job Description

POSITION SUMMARY:

The Litigation Group in India handles a variety of crucial tasks, including intake, billing, automation and research. Intake process is the first step in ensuring that Ocwen pays proper attention to any and all legal issues brought to its attention. The Litigation Intake process includes – Pre Intake, Post Intake and Auxiliary Process. As a loan servicer, Ocwen is responsible for managing all litigation related to a loan on behalf of the investor/trust of the loan. This means that Ocwen will manage litigation stemming from routine mortgage issues such as foreclosures to personal injury caused by a slip and fall at an REO (real estate owned – post-foreclosure) property. Ocwen’s Law Department also manages any litigation naming Ocwen entities directly. Through the intake process, legal mail will be sent to the proper business unit for handling, which may not be the Law Department.

The present position i.e. Litigation Intake Analyst is with Litigation Group in India and will report to the Supervisor/Assistant Manager, Law Litigation department.

JOB FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES

• Provide assistance to U.S. Litigation Team by assisting with the review of legal mail and identifying the loan number, property address, investor/trust details that corresponds to the legal mail.
• Requires strict compliance, as all legal mail received must be processed on the same day that analyst receives it.
• Pull data from various data bases in order to analyze loan and enter said information into analysis sheet and/or data base.
• Assist with transferring of legal mail to other departments and ensuring said transfer is documented in data base.
• Process subpoenas.
• Opening and Closing of Legal matters
• Assist with imaging, scanning and uploading documents into data base
• Providing legal status update to the BU as requested
• Support other litigation intake analysts with overflow or any additional duties.

• EDUCATION / EXPERIENCE
• Bachelor’s Degree required
• Preferably 1+ year of experience in MNC BPO
• Successful candidate must have good computer skills.
• Excellent verbal and written communication skills
• Ability to work on multiple projects and also periodically set and achieve stretch goals
• Candidate must have good judgment, high attention to detail and be able to immediately escalate problematic or difficult issues.
• The position opened is for night shift since the candidate is required to work during the US timings (preferably the EST timings)

WORK SCHEDULE OR TRAVEL REQUIREMENTS (Only add if needed)

6:30 PM to 3:30 PM

How to Apply?

https://jobs.ocwen.com/jobs/7226644-intake-analyst-law-litigation?utm_medium=jobboard&utm_source=linkedin

For regular updates, join us:

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WKtP

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

The Present article has been written by Gracy Singh, pursuing BA. LL.B.(Hons.)(2nd year) from Mody University of Science and Technology, Lakshmangarh, Rajasthan.

INTRODUCTION

India used to believe in the concepts like “Matri Devo Bhava” (the woman is revered to God), and “Yatra naryastu pujyante ramante tatra, Devata, yatraitaastu na pujyante sarvaastatrafalaah kriyaah” (Divinity blossom where women are honored, where women have dishonored all actions remain unfruitful). This concept seems to disappear in the present time as the number of sexual offenses against women keeps increasing. One such sexual offense which has become the most common crime in India is Rape. It is the most heinous crime as well as a huge disgrace to humankind. Rape means having sexual intercourse without the consent of another person. 

According to National Crime Records Bureau’s (NCRB), 88 rape cases per day, and 32,033 in the year were reported in India in the year 2019. The list is topped by Rajasthan (6,000 rape cases), and Uttar Pradesh (3,065 rape cases).  These are reported cases there are the majority of crimes against women committed by know people such as family members, friends, and neighbors; whereas in some cases victims are coerced by their families to keep silent. Who should be blamed for this?

LAWS REGARDING RAPE IN INDIA 

1. India Penal Code, 1860 – 

In the Indian Penal Code, Section 375 states that rape is said to have been committed when a man has sexual intercourse with a woman without her consent or against the free will or obtains consent by force, fear of death, or by making her believe that the person is married to her, during the unsoundness of her mind, or intoxication.

2. The Criminal Law (Second Amendment), 1983 

In the case, Tukaram v. the State of Maharashtra commonly known as Mathura Rape Case, a girl Mathura aged between 14-16 years, was raped by two police constables. Her family filed a case against two constables. The court said that Mathura did not call out for help and there were no visible marks on her body, so the act was consensual. The court further added that she was habitual to sexual intercourse. 

This case triggered endless violence across the nation; it was observed that the verdict given by the court was not sensible, legitimate, and linguistic. Women started protests demanding modification in the law. 

In 1983, The Criminal Law (Second Amendment) was brought that amended the Indian Evidence Act, Section 114 (A) was added stating that if the victim says that there was no consent, the court shall presume that there was no consent given. Custodial Rape was made punishable, and the character assassination was prohibited of the rape victim in court by this amendment.

3. Amendment to Indian Evidence Act, 2002 

In 1983, character assassination was prohibited but cross-examination of the rape victim was not defined. An NGO, Sakshi filed a PIL pointing out the humiliation, dishonor of the sexual integrity, and personal space faced by the victims during trials in the court. 

Later, the Supreme Court ordered the Law Commission to review rape laws and to recommend the changes. As per Section 155(4) of the Indian Evidence Act, 2002, a defense lawyer could dishonor the testimony by proving the immoral character of the victim. Therefore, this clause was amended in 2002, and the cross-examination of the victim was prohibited. 

4. Protection of Children from Sexual Offence Act (POCSO), 2012

As per the statistical data, Indian reported a 336% increase in child rape cases from 2001 to 2011. NCRB statistics showed that 48,338 child cases were reported during this period. This led to an urgent need for a law for child victims of sexual offenses.  It is gender-neutral and includes the abetment of child sexual abuses, sexual harassment, child pornography, and non-penetrative assault. Hence, POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Offenses Act) was passed in 2012. This Act made the police in charge to ensure the protection of the child during the investigating process, and provide medical treatment in emergencies. Also, the courts were allowed the conduct the in-camera trial without revealing the true identity of the child. The Act also made it mandatory to report child sexual offense cases.

5. Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013

In 2012, Mukesh and Anrs. v. NCT Delhi and Ors. a 23-year-old girl was brutally gang-raped in a moving bus, which led to her death. This led to protest in the country, demanding not only amendment in the laws but also the perspective towards rape. It became a women’s rights issue in India. This case also led to reconsider the laws as well as realizing that still there are many crimes against women that are not mentioned in our legal framework such as stalking, voyeurism, acid attacks. 

This led to the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, that added stalking, voyeurism, and acid attacks into the definition of rape, a threat to rape is also considered as a crime. The punishment for rape was changed from seven years to ten years, in case of vegetative state or death of the victim, the punishment was increased to 20 years. The age was changed from 18 to 16 to the Juvenile Justice Act for being tried for crimes like murder, and murder since one of the accused in this case was minor.

6. Criminal Law (Amendment) Ordinance

In 2018, an 8 years old girl was gang-raped and murdered by two men and a juvenile in Kathua, a district in Jammu and Kashmir. This case led to outrage among the masses in the nation. An amendment was brought in POCSO, and made rape punishable of a child below 16 years, as well as the minimum punishment, was made 20 years of imprisonment and death penalty in case of death of a child below the age of 12. The fast-track clause was amended from a year to six months.

PROBLEMS IN THE RAPE LAWS  

1. Justice delayed, justice denied

In the case of the Delhi Medical student rape case, the fast-track court was set up, and it wrapped up the proceedings of the case within eight months. The convicts were given the death penalty but it took more than seven years to hang them. In 2019, more than 1.66 lakh cases are pending in Fast Track Courts; there will be no final closure even though all the legal formalities are completed and judgment is passed by FTCs. Fast-track justice could instill fear among the people.

2. Gender Biased

It is time for society to understand and accept that men can also be the victim of trape. The most affected groups by the gender-biased laws are transgender and non-binary persons who more often face abuse and sexual assault. Lawmaker needs to understand that any person can be a victim and a perpetrator. Law should not be amended to claim that both men and women are affected by rape in the same manner rather an amendment should change the way society sees gendered stereotypes of sexuality.

3. Botched investigations, few convictions

The police are considered shoddy as they do not know how to collect evidence like samples, photographs, fingerprints, and the crime scene is rarely protected. This results in poor prosecutions, few convictions, and amiable jail terms for offenders who are convicted.

4. Stricter Laws

In India, rape is a common crime, the majority of cases go unreported. The accused in most of the cases are known or trusted people. As the laws are made stricter and also have the death penalty in some rape cases, victims are murdered so that they cannot tell or lodge a complaint against the perpetrators. 

5. The Legality of Child Marriage 

The Supreme Court read exception 2 of section 375 and held that an act of sexual intercourse of a man with his minor wife will amount to rape. A marriage between a minor girl with an adult is voidable at the girl’s choice but it not completely void. Child marriage is granted legitimacy. Therefore, an adult can have sexual intercourse with his minor wife, but unless it is not reported this will not be a crime. In India, the probability is that number of such cases will remain unreported. But declaring child marriage void could stop this crime against minors.

6. Statutory Rape

It is defined under Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code states that if any man has intercourse with any girl below 18 years, with or without her consent will constitute statutory rape.

There is no difference left between sex between an adult and a minor, or two consenting minors because minors are considered to not have enough knowledge to give consent for sex. In such cases, sometimes the boys involved are unjustly convicted under the statutory rape clause. In a case, the Madras High Court said as obiter dicta that sexual activities between minors above the age of 16 should not be criminalized.

7. Marital Rape

India is one of 36 countries where marital rape is legalized. However, the UN Committee on Elimination of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), as well as the  Justice Verma Committee, recommended criminalizing marital rape. Still, there is no law to protect women from marital rape. It violates the right to live with dignity (Article 21), and the right to privacy, only women below or 18 years of age are protected from marital rape but what about the women above 18 years? 

Case Study –

Kajal (not her real name), Madhya Pradesh

Kajal, a rape victim who was 23, said that after she filed a complaint of gang rape in the Neemuch district of Madhya Pradesh, she, and her father was detained, threatened, and beaten up by the police. She was slapped, beaten up with a stick, and compelled to sign on several blank papers, and forced to give a false statement in court or her father will be arrested on false charges. Police filed a closure report stating that Kajal and her father had filed a false case against the man accused because of the land dispute between them. However, the closure report was rejected, and the investigation officer was summoned by the chief judicial magistrate. 

Due to threatening from the accused Kajal’s parents asked her to move away from their home before her in-laws abandoned her when she filed a report of rape. When she was in urgent need of medical and counseling support but she was not provided with any referral for counseling.

CONCLUSION

Many changes have been brought in rape laws since 1860 and tried to bring the change in the existing condition of women but still, there are changes required such as criminalizing marital rape. Some laws end up having some negative effects. Every time a big rape case is noticed, the nation is shaken by the outrage and public demanding modification. However, many unreported cases also do not get similar public attention. In current rape laws changes and additions are required. It is time to bring some changes and fight this evil proactively. 

Latest Posts

• Job opportunity at EXO Edge, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
• Internship opportunity at Vishwas Advisors, Kalyan, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Internship opportunity at Kulfi Collective, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!
• Job opportunity at The Neotia University, Diamond Harbour, West Bengal, India: Apply Now !!
• Job opportunity at Morgan Stanley, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at VISA INTELLIGENCE CONSULTANCY LLP, New Delhi, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!  
• Job opportunity at Amazon Web Services (AWS), Gurugram, Haryana, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Stelcore Management Services Private Limited, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Zscaler, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Irish Expert, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at UnitedLex · Gurgaon, Haryana, India: Apply Now!
• Internship opportunity at Vineforce · Nabha, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!

---

• ACEDY (1)
• CLAT-Peeps! (10)
  • Current Affairs (2)
• competitions (132)
• Conferences and Seminars (201)
  • Webinar (1)
• Course and Workshops (107)
• Debates (46)
• DEGY (1)
• Eassy Competitions (69)
• Fellowships & Scholarships (56)
• Guest Blogs (6)
• important (29)
• Internships and Jobs (2,317)
• interviews (8)
• LEGY (1)
• moot court (180)
• Opportuintes (2,731)
  • Job Opportunity (1,191)
• opportunity (2,559)
  • Call for papers (475)
  • Quizes,fests and others (298)
  • Work Opportunity (836)
• Our Blog (1,049)
  • Administrative Law (17)
  • ADR (13)
  • Arms Act (2)
  • Case Analysis (205)
  • Company law (36)
  • Constitutional Law (143)
  • Consumer Protection Act (17)
  • Contract Law (62)
  • CPC (10)
  • Criminal Law (140)
  • Cyber Law (13)
  • Environmental Laws (30)
  • Evidence Act (20)
  • Family Law (12)
  • General (205)
  • International Humanitarian Law (8)
  • International law (23)
  • IPR (10)
  • Jurisprudence (13)
  • labor laws (7)
  • Maritime Laws (1)
  • Partnership Act (2)
  • personal law (33)
  • Taxation (10)
  • Tort (64)
  • Transfer of Property (2)
• Our Services (11)
  • career advice (2)
  • others (6)
• Top Stories (524)
• Uncategorized (720)

Archives

• November 2023 (26)
• October 2023 (1)
• September 2023 (5)
• August 2023 (2)
• July 2023 (25)
• June 2023 (23)
• May 2023 (40)
• April 2023 (136)
• March 2023 (124)
• February 2023 (138)
• January 2023 (61)
• December 2022 (39)
• November 2022 (103)
• October 2022 (178)
• September 2022 (342)
• August 2022 (240)
• July 2022 (273)
• June 2022 (196)
• May 2022 (27)
• April 2022 (99)
• March 2022 (190)
• February 2022 (196)
• January 2022 (193)
• December 2021 (152)
• November 2021 (203)
• October 2021 (189)
• September 2021 (177)
• August 2021 (192)
• July 2021 (393)
• June 2021 (293)
• May 2021 (179)
• April 2021 (61)
• March 2021 (46)
• February 2021 (56)
• January 2021 (63)
• December 2020 (86)
• November 2020 (94)
• October 2020 (146)
• September 2020 (220)
• August 2020 (173)
• July 2020 (165)
• June 2020 (119)
• May 2020 (136)
• April 2020 (7)
• February 2020 (37)
• January 2020 (3)
• November 2019 (1)

The present article has been written by Prateek Chandgothia, pursuing BA. LL.B. (1st year) from the Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law, Punjab.

India witnessed one of the gravest rape cases in December 2012 which shook the national capital and subsequently the whole of India. Wide-spread protests broke out through the country demanding the justice of the rape victim, who was designated with the title of Nirbhaya for the level of mental toughness and endurance portrayed by her. Various legislations were passed in the aftermath of the incident as the four accused were awarded the death penalty and were hanged to death on 20^th March 2020. The 8-year long wait for justice paints a disturbing picture of the Indian criminal justice system and indicates the necessity of speedy trials in rape cases.

Legislative Analysis of Rape Laws

The Indian Penal Code criminalizes rape as a sexual offense under Section 375-377. Rape is defined under Section 375 of the IPC as “sexual intercourse with a woman against her will, without her consent, by coercion, misrepresentation or fraud or at a time when she has been intoxicated or duped or is of unsound mental health and in any case if she is under 18 years of age.” The Criminal Law (Second Amendment) Act was enacted in 1983 which marked a paradigm shift like the rape laws in India by strengthening the position of women in such cases. Section 114A was introduced in the Indian Evidence Act of 1872 which stated that it must be presumed that there is the absence of consent in certain prosecutions of rape if the victim says so. Furthermore, Section 228A was introduced in the IPC which makes it punishable to disclose the identity of the victim of certain offenses including rape. 

In the aftermath of the Nirbhaya Rape Case, The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2013 was enacted. It expanded the scope of rape by including offenses like the use of criminal force on a woman with intent to disrobe, voyeurism, stalking, use of unwelcome physical contact, words or gestures, demands, or requests for sexual favors, showing pornography against the will of a woman, or making sexual remarks. Along with the extension of the scope of rape, the punishments were also increased significantly through this amendment. The act increased jail terms in most sexual assault cases and also provided for the death penalty in rape cases that cause the death of the victim or leaves her in a vegetative state. The punishment of gang rape was increased to 20 years to life imprisonment from 10 years to life imprisonment. The punishment of stalking was set at imprisonment for 3 years and punishment for the acid attack was set at 10 years of imprisonment. The amendments were not confined to the Indian Penal Code as the 172^nd Law Commission report led to amendments in the Indian Evidence (Amendment) Act of 2002 which further strengthened the position of women in rape cases. The new provision barred putting questions in the cross-examination of the victim as to her general ‘immoral character’ in rape or attempt to rape cases. However, the effect of these legislations has been negligible in terms of statistics as according to the National Crime Record Bureau, a woman is raped every 16 minutes and 88 rape cases are recorded daily. In 2019 alone, 32,033 rape cases were recorded. Therefore, these legislations have not deterred the occurrence of rape cases in India.

Fast Track Courts: A Reality Check

Fast Courts have been a part of the Indian legal system since 2000 which gained significance after the Nirbhaya Rape Case in 2012. The main objective of these courts was to deal with the crime against women, child trafficking under POCSO Act, crime against senior citizens, crime against the disabled, and other heinous crimes. As quoted by the 11^th Finance Commission of 2000, the fast-track courts are recommended: “to substantially bring down, if not eliminate, pendency in the district and subordinate courts over the next five years”.

However, various statistics indicate an entirely contrasting situation. According to the NCRB data, trials in fast-track courts take longer than trials in regular courts. It is reported that out of more than 28,000 trials completed in India’s fast-track courts in 2018, only 22% took less than a year to complete. This is the lowest percentage among all kinds of courts including SC/ ST courts, Additional Session Judge Courts, District/ Session Judge Courts, POCSO Court, Sub-Judge Courts, Special Courts, and Special Judicial Magistrates. Furthermore, around 42% of the total trials took more than 3 years to complete, while 17% took more than five years to complete. These statistics indicate that the fast-track courts have failed in achieving the very objective for which they were established.

It is essential to note that the mere establishment of fast-track courts is not sufficient in countering the inadvertent delays in the trial of the rape cases. Various inefficiencies have infested the working and establishment of the fast-track courts. Fast-track courts have been established under the centrally sponsored scheme of allocation of funds which is overseen by the Department of Justice. The scheme was established in 1993 stating that 60% of the funds must come from the center and 40% of the funds must come from the states. In 2020-21, Rs. 767 crores were approved for the construction of 1,023 fast-track courts under The POCSO act, 2012 based on the centrally sponsored scheme. The particular scheme leads to disparity in fund distribution among states which was evident when the Maharashtra Government sanctioned the construction of 138 courts with the expected cost of Rs. 100 crores. This extracts Rs. 60 crores as the share from the center leaving only on an average, a sum of Rs. 26 crores for the other states. 

Various veterans in the field of criminal law have pointed out various flaws in the mechanism of fast-track courts indicating that they are similar to the regular courts, if not worse. It is stated that the nomenclature of ‘fast-track’ courts exists just in the name and not in the functioning of the courts as the judges and the procedure are identical in nature. Various procedural inefficiencies have been pointed out like the witnesses not coming on time, lawyers not turning up and while the judges don’t have the power to discipline them, the bar councils don’t take any action against them. Recording of evidence is a major stage in a trial that concerns grave violations and plays a significant role in the delay in the delivery of judgment. The longer duration of trials in special fast-tracked courts has been justified by the serious and complicated nature of the cases they deal with as they require recording of more evidence than regular cases.

Effective legal assistance is an important factor missing from the remedies provided to sexual assault victims. The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare issued guidelines for medico-legal care for survivors of sexual violence intending to standardize healthcare professionals’ examination and treatment of sexual assault survivors. The guidelines provide scientific medical information and processes that aid in correcting pervasive myths. However, under the federal structure of India, health is a state subject and therefore, the states are not bound to follow the said guidelines. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in a 1994 case ruled that police should provide sexual assault victims legal assistance and keep a list of legal aid options which do often not conform to. 

Moreover, victimization of the aggrieved is still prevalent at great lengths in the Indian Legal system and the social fabric of the country. The delay in judgment delivery often leads to the promotion of speculations which encourage issues like victim-blaming, dilution of passion towards a goal, increased mental agony for the victim and their family. Therefore, it is the need of the hour to recognize these flaws and implement corrective measures to ensure speedy trials in rape cases.

Conclusion 

Despite the progressive development in legislations and specialized fast-track courts, the main objective, which is a speedy trial, remains unachieved to this day. Various state and center initiatives have fallen through mainly because of the lack of monitoring mechanisms and frameworks. In view of this article, in order to ensure the implementation of speedy trials in rape cases can be a reality only if an efficient mechanism that involves suitable procedural laws and specialized judges, is implemented.  

Latest Posts

• Job opportunity at EXO Edge, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
• Internship opportunity at Vishwas Advisors, Kalyan, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Internship opportunity at Kulfi Collective, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!
• Job opportunity at The Neotia University, Diamond Harbour, West Bengal, India: Apply Now !!
• Job opportunity at Morgan Stanley, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at VISA INTELLIGENCE CONSULTANCY LLP, New Delhi, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!  
• Job opportunity at Amazon Web Services (AWS), Gurugram, Haryana, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Stelcore Management Services Private Limited, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Zscaler, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Irish Expert, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at UnitedLex · Gurgaon, Haryana, India: Apply Now!
• Internship opportunity at Vineforce · Nabha, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!

---

• ACEDY (1)
• CLAT-Peeps! (10)
  • Current Affairs (2)
• competitions (132)
• Conferences and Seminars (201)
  • Webinar (1)
• Course and Workshops (107)
• Debates (46)
• DEGY (1)
• Eassy Competitions (69)
• Fellowships & Scholarships (56)
• Guest Blogs (6)
• important (29)
• Internships and Jobs (2,317)
• interviews (8)
• LEGY (1)
• moot court (180)
• Opportuintes (2,731)
  • Job Opportunity (1,191)
• opportunity (2,559)
  • Call for papers (475)
  • Quizes,fests and others (298)
  • Work Opportunity (836)
• Our Blog (1,049)
  • Administrative Law (17)
  • ADR (13)
  • Arms Act (2)
  • Case Analysis (205)
  • Company law (36)
  • Constitutional Law (143)
  • Consumer Protection Act (17)
  • Contract Law (62)
  • CPC (10)
  • Criminal Law (140)
  • Cyber Law (13)
  • Environmental Laws (30)
  • Evidence Act (20)
  • Family Law (12)
  • General (205)
  • International Humanitarian Law (8)
  • International law (23)
  • IPR (10)
  • Jurisprudence (13)
  • labor laws (7)
  • Maritime Laws (1)
  • Partnership Act (2)
  • personal law (33)
  • Taxation (10)
  • Tort (64)
  • Transfer of Property (2)
• Our Services (11)
  • career advice (2)
  • others (6)
• Top Stories (524)
• Uncategorized (720)

Archives

• November 2023 (26)
• October 2023 (1)
• September 2023 (5)
• August 2023 (2)
• July 2023 (25)
• June 2023 (23)
• May 2023 (40)
• April 2023 (136)
• March 2023 (124)
• February 2023 (138)
• January 2023 (61)
• December 2022 (39)
• November 2022 (103)
• October 2022 (178)
• September 2022 (342)
• August 2022 (240)
• July 2022 (273)
• June 2022 (196)
• May 2022 (27)
• April 2022 (99)
• March 2022 (190)
• February 2022 (196)
• January 2022 (193)
• December 2021 (152)
• November 2021 (203)
• October 2021 (189)
• September 2021 (177)
• August 2021 (192)
• July 2021 (393)
• June 2021 (293)
• May 2021 (179)
• April 2021 (61)
• March 2021 (46)
• February 2021 (56)
• January 2021 (63)
• December 2020 (86)
• November 2020 (94)
• October 2020 (146)
• September 2020 (220)
• August 2020 (173)
• July 2020 (165)
• June 2020 (119)
• May 2020 (136)
• April 2020 (7)
• February 2020 (37)
• January 2020 (3)
• November 2019 (1)

The present article has been written by Sanjana Suman, a student of Amity Law School, Ranchi.

Introduction

The labour movement was the driving force behind the transformation of despair and misery into hope and progress. The economic and social transformation gave rise to unemployment insurance, old-age pensions, government assistance for the poor, and, most importantly, new pay levels that meant more than just survival but a liveable life. The industrialists did not lead this shift; instead, they fought it until they were defeated. When the tide of union organisation crests over the nation in the 1930s, it carries not only itself but the entire society to safe shores.

Trade unions are an important part of any country’s modern industrial relations system, with each having its own set of objectives or goals to attain in accordance with its constitution, as well as its own strategy for achieving those goals. A trade union is a group of workers who band together to protect their interests and better their working circumstances. It is a continuing organisation of wage earners whose goal is to keep and improve working conditions (Dankert, 1948). The right to organise a union and bargain collectively protects workers in developing nations from exploitative and abusive working conditions and puts pressure on companies to share productivity gains with their workers. In order for the working population in emerging countries to realise the advantages of economic growth, basic worker and human rights must be protected (Ghosh & to, 2007).

Why Trade Unions?

There is no definitive response to this question, owing to the fact that each worker’s reasons for joining trade unions are unique. Workers don’t join unions only to receive higher income or better working conditions, according to studies, though these are crucial criteria. According to recent research, the average income for union members was 781 dollars, while the average income for non-union workers was 612 dollars. They also get additional vacation days, sick days, unpaid time off, insurance coverage, and other perks that non-union workers do not. According to studies, the major reasons why workers join unions are employer unfairness and the union’s clout.

The final line is that the desire to join a labour union is frequently motivated by a belief held by workers. They believe that the only way to protect themselves against management is to band together. In practice, low morale, fear of losing one’s job, and arbitrary management decisions all contribute to the growth of unions. A poll of nurses, for example, indicated that trade unions are founded when employees are treated unfairly, as well as being underpaid, hazardous, and unappreciated.

To Employees:

The wages of union members are generally higher than those of non-unionised workers.

In some cases, trade unions can serve as legal advocates for workers.

Employees’ rights are now more safeguarded. They cannot, for example, be fired without cause.

To Employers:

Workers are more motivated because their individual rights are more safeguarded and represented. Higher levels of efficiency and production result as a result of this.

Importance of Trade unions-

The origins of labour unions can be traced back to the 18^th century when the fast expansion of industrial civilisation drew in significant numbers of women, children, and immigrants. Toward the close of the nineteenth century, the Catholic Church also encouraged trade unions. Industrial peace necessitates the existence of a powerful and well-recognised trade union. The decisions reached through collective bargaining and talks between employers and unions have a greater impact. Trade unions play a crucial role in facilitating effective communication between workers and management. They offer guidance and help to ensure that disagreements do not escalate into serious disputes. A trade union’s main purpose is to represent individuals at work. They do, however, play a larger role in safeguarding their own interests. They also serve as key educational institutions, hosting classes for their members on a variety of topics. A key component of union activity is the pursuit of a healthy and safe working environment.

• By helping in the recruitment and selection of workers.
• By inculcating discipline among the workforce
• By enabling settlement of industrial disputes in a rational manner
• By helping social adjustments. Workers have to adjust themselves to the new working conditions, the new rules, and policies. Workers from various backgrounds may become disorganized, dissatisfied, and frustrated as a result of their work environment. Unions assist them in making such adjustments.

Objectives of Trade Union:

(1) To improve employees’ economic circumstances by achieving higher wages.

(2) To provide improved working conditions for employees.

(3) To ensure that the workers receive a bonus from the company’s revenues.

(4) To provide workers with steady employment and to oppose management practices that restrict job prospects.

(5) To provide legal help to workers in the event of a labour dispute or wage payment issue.

(6) To preserve labour positions from retrenchment and layoffs, among other things.

(7) To ensure that workers get provident funds, pensions, and other benefits in accordance with the rules.

(8) To ensure that workers’ safety and health are better protected.

(9) To ensure that workers are involved in management.

(10) To instill in workers discipline, self-respect, and dignity.

Advantages of Trade Union 

1. Working with a union saves time in pay discussions when compared to dealing with individuals. This is especially important in the case of supervisors and managers, as it aids in the promotion of appropriate remuneration plans and the avoidance of inequity and probable resentment.

2. Employees can more easily be provided a picture of the organisation’s problems and so gain a better grasp of them through meetings with shop stewards and local union leaders when there is mutual respect, that is when morale is high. As a result, better labour relations should emerge.

3. Workers recognise the value of unionisation and are able to engage in constructive talks about working practices, disciplinary measures, and other issues with the help of union representatives. Worker dissidents are often contained by the majority of workers when relations are excellent.

4. Working together with a trade union may make it easier for an organisation to fulfill the requirements imposed on employers by government rules and statutes.

5. With union cooperation, changes in working habits and necessary redeployment of personnel can be done more quickly. When redundancies are unavoidable, union participation can be very beneficial in securing adequate compensation for individuals who are affected.

Conclusion

In India, trade unionism has come a long way. From having no legal backing to making union “strikes” illegal, to granting them registration and mandatory recognition, to now having full-fledged law and special courts, India’s trade unions have achieved amazing prestige and stature in the labour movement. However, trade unions continue to encounter challenges such as a lack of financial resources and government assistance. As a result, there is still room for trade unionism to grow in India. 

Latest Posts

• Job opportunity at EXO Edge, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
• Internship opportunity at Vishwas Advisors, Kalyan, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Internship opportunity at Kulfi Collective, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!
• Job opportunity at The Neotia University, Diamond Harbour, West Bengal, India: Apply Now !!
• Job opportunity at Morgan Stanley, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at VISA INTELLIGENCE CONSULTANCY LLP, New Delhi, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!  
• Job opportunity at Amazon Web Services (AWS), Gurugram, Haryana, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Stelcore Management Services Private Limited, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Zscaler, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at Irish Expert, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!
• Job opportunity at UnitedLex · Gurgaon, Haryana, India: Apply Now!
• Internship opportunity at Vineforce · Nabha, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!

---

• ACEDY (1)
• CLAT-Peeps! (10)
  • Current Affairs (2)
• competitions (132)
• Conferences and Seminars (201)
  • Webinar (1)
• Course and Workshops (107)
• Debates (46)
• DEGY (1)
• Eassy Competitions (69)
• Fellowships & Scholarships (56)
• Guest Blogs (6)
• important (29)
• Internships and Jobs (2,317)
• interviews (8)
• LEGY (1)
• moot court (180)
• Opportuintes (2,731)
  • Job Opportunity (1,191)
• opportunity (2,559)
  • Call for papers (475)
  • Quizes,fests and others (298)
  • Work Opportunity (836)
• Our Blog (1,049)
  • Administrative Law (17)
  • ADR (13)
  • Arms Act (2)
  • Case Analysis (205)
  • Company law (36)
  • Constitutional Law (143)
  • Consumer Protection Act (17)
  • Contract Law (62)
  • CPC (10)
  • Criminal Law (140)
  • Cyber Law (13)
  • Environmental Laws (30)
  • Evidence Act (20)
  • Family Law (12)
  • General (205)
  • International Humanitarian Law (8)
  • International law (23)
  • IPR (10)
  • Jurisprudence (13)
  • labor laws (7)
  • Maritime Laws (1)
  • Partnership Act (2)
  • personal law (33)
  • Taxation (10)
  • Tort (64)
  • Transfer of Property (2)
• Our Services (11)
  • career advice (2)
  • others (6)
• Top Stories (524)
• Uncategorized (720)

Archives

• November 2023 (26)
• October 2023 (1)
• September 2023 (5)
• August 2023 (2)
• July 2023 (25)
• June 2023 (23)
• May 2023 (40)
• April 2023 (136)
• March 2023 (124)
• February 2023 (138)
• January 2023 (61)
• December 2022 (39)
• November 2022 (103)
• October 2022 (178)
• September 2022 (342)
• August 2022 (240)
• July 2022 (273)
• June 2022 (196)
• May 2022 (27)
• April 2022 (99)
• March 2022 (190)
• February 2022 (196)
• January 2022 (193)
• December 2021 (152)
• November 2021 (203)
• October 2021 (189)
• September 2021 (177)
• August 2021 (192)
• July 2021 (393)
• June 2021 (293)
• May 2021 (179)
• April 2021 (61)
• March 2021 (46)
• February 2021 (56)
• January 2021 (63)
• December 2020 (86)
• November 2020 (94)
• October 2020 (146)
• September 2020 (220)
• August 2020 (173)
• July 2020 (165)
• June 2020 (119)
• May 2020 (136)
• April 2020 (7)
• February 2020 (37)
• January 2020 (3)
• November 2019 (1)