Case Number
Civil Appeal No. 5837 of 2006 with Contempt Petition (C) No. 38 of 2006.
Equivalent citation
(2007) 3 SCC 169.
Bench
S.B. Sinha, Markandey Katju.
Date Of Judgment
15/12/2006
Relevant Act
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005
Facts
The petitioner Smt. Taruna Batra was married to Amit Batra, son of the respondent, on 14th April 2000. After the marriage, Taruna Batra was living with Amit Batra in her in-law’s house. Amit Batra has filed a divorce petition against his wife. In response, Taruna Batra also filed an F.I.R. against his husband, mother-in-law, father-in-law, and sister-in-law under Indian Penal Code Section 406, 498A, 506, and 34. They were arrested by police and after three days they got bail. Taruna Batra started living in her mother’s house. Later, she tried to enter the appellant’s house, but she could not enter because of the lock. Amit Batra had bought a house in Ghaziabad and was living there.
Arguments
The argument made by the petitioner
Smt. Trauma Batra has raised the issue that she has the right to live in the respondent’s house because it is her matrimonial house.
The argument made by respondent
The petitioner has no right because it cannot be her matrimonial house. After all, her husband is not living in the suit property. Her matrimonial house had shifted to her husband’s new house.
The issue before the Court
- A woman has the right to reside in the shared household of her husband. Shared household which is defined under Section 2(s) of the Domestic Violence Act, 2005.
Lower Court Judgment
The Senior Civil Judge held that Amit Batra was not living with his parents at their house. Hence, home does not mean where the wife was residing. The respondent had only right to her husband’s property.
After the Lower Court decision Smt. Trauma Batra filed a petition in the High court under Article 227.
High Court Judgment
The High Court held that in India, there is no specific law like the British Matrimonial Homes Act, 1967. The rights may be provided under any statute against the husband’s property and but not against in law’s house. The suit property belongs to her mother-in-law and it does not belong to her husband.
Supreme Court Judgment
The Supreme Court held that a wife is entitled to reside in a shared household which is defined under Section 2(s) Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. A Shared household means the house belongs or is taken by the aggrieved person or the husband and property which belongs to a joint family where the husband is a member. The court decided Smt. Trauma Batra has the right to reside in her matrimonial home. But the Court also held that the wife has no right to reside in the residence which is owned by her in-laws whether it is a matrimonial home. The court observed the High Court decision and disagreed with the High Court concerning the Matrimonial Homes Act which does not exist in India.
Conclusion
The issue is ruling in the case that the wife has the right to reside in a shared household where the husband owns some share. In the decision of the Supreme Court, there is some fallacy in the definition of the shared household.
The case analysis has been done by Prachi Yadav, a 2nd-year student from Mody University of Science and Technology, Lakshmangarh, Rajasthan.
The case analysis has been edited by Shubham Yadav, a 4th-year Law student of Banasthali Vidyapith.
Latest Posts
- Job opportunity at EXO Edge, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
- Internship opportunity at Vishwas Advisors, Kalyan, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
- Internship opportunity at Kulfi Collective, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!
- Job opportunity at The Neotia University, Diamond Harbour, West Bengal, India: Apply Now !!
- Job opportunity at Morgan Stanley, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at VISA INTELLIGENCE CONSULTANCY LLP, New Delhi, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at Amazon Web Services (AWS), Gurugram, Haryana, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at Stelcore Management Services Private Limited, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at Zscaler, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at Irish Expert, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at UnitedLex · Gurgaon, Haryana, India: Apply Now!
- Internship opportunity at Vineforce · Nabha, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
- CLAT-Peeps! (10)
- Current Affairs (2)
- competitions (132)
- Conferences and Seminars (201)
- Webinar (1)
- Course and Workshops (107)
- Debates (46)
- Eassy Competitions (69)
- Fellowships & Scholarships (56)
- Guest Blogs (6)
- important (29)
- Internships and Jobs (2,317)
- interviews (8)
- moot court (180)
- Opportuintes (2,731)
- Job Opportunity (1,191)
- opportunity (2,559)
- Call for papers (475)
- Quizes,fests and others (298)
- Work Opportunity (836)
- Our Blog (1,049)
- Administrative Law (17)
- ADR (13)
- Arms Act (2)
- Case Analysis (205)
- Company law (36)
- Constitutional Law (143)
- Consumer Protection Act (17)
- Contract Law (62)
- CPC (10)
- Criminal Law (140)
- Cyber Law (13)
- Environmental Laws (30)
- Evidence Act (20)
- Family Law (12)
- General (205)
- International Humanitarian Law (8)
- International law (23)
- IPR (10)
- Jurisprudence (13)
- labor laws (7)
- Maritime Laws (1)
- Partnership Act (2)
- personal law (33)
- Taxation (10)
- Tort (64)
- Transfer of Property (2)
- Our Services (11)
- career advice (2)
- others (6)
- Top Stories (524)
- Uncategorized (720)
Archives
- November 2023 (26)
- October 2023 (1)
- September 2023 (5)
- August 2023 (2)
- July 2023 (25)
- June 2023 (23)
- May 2023 (40)
- April 2023 (136)
- March 2023 (124)
- February 2023 (138)
- January 2023 (61)
- December 2022 (39)
- November 2022 (103)
- October 2022 (178)
- September 2022 (342)
- August 2022 (240)
- July 2022 (273)
- June 2022 (196)
- May 2022 (27)
- April 2022 (99)
- March 2022 (190)
- February 2022 (196)
- January 2022 (193)
- December 2021 (152)
- November 2021 (203)
- October 2021 (189)
- September 2021 (177)
- August 2021 (192)
- July 2021 (393)
- June 2021 (293)
- May 2021 (179)
- April 2021 (61)
- March 2021 (46)
- February 2021 (56)
- January 2021 (63)
- December 2020 (86)
- November 2020 (94)
- October 2020 (146)
- September 2020 (220)
- August 2020 (173)
- July 2020 (165)
- June 2020 (119)
- May 2020 (136)
- April 2020 (7)
- February 2020 (37)
- January 2020 (3)
- November 2019 (1)