This article has been written by Yash Mittal. Picture credits to damajority.com
What is National Security?
National security is the concept of a government, with its parliament that should protect the state and its citizens against all kinds of national threats and crises. It is mainly for protection against military attack but now national security also includes other dimensions, which include the security from terrorism, environmental security, cybersecurity, economic security, etc.
The concept of national security is mostly developed in the United States after World War II. It’s initial focus it’s on military attack, but now it covers the broad range, which impinge on the non-military and economic security of the nation.
In order to possess national security, nation needs to possess economic security, environmental security, energy security etc. Security threats involve not only conventional foes such as other nation-states but also non-state actors such as violent non-state actors, narcotic cartels, multinational co-operations, and Non-governmental organizations (NGO’s), and also includes natural disasters and events causing environmental damage.
Harold Lasswell described national security as freedom from foreign dictation. And Walter Lippman described national security as a nation that has security when it does not have to sacrifice it’s legitimate interests to avoid war and is able if challenged to maintain them by war.
Issues Related to National Security
Military forces place a huge burden on economic security because of its high maintaining cost. Government expenditure on state armed forces was 4% in 2015 in Germany, 14% in the USA, 9% in the chile, 15% in Israel, 19% in Pakistan.
India’s military spending grew by 6.8 percent to $71.1 billion in 2019 according to the SIPRO report and trends in world military expenditure 2019. This is the highest military spending in South Asia.
And India is now the third biggest military spending in the world. If not done so, economic constraints can limit the capabilities of the military.
Unilateral actions related to security by the states can also impact the political security at the international level if it erodes the rule of law and undermining the authority of international institutions.
In competition with other nation-states for the betterment of economic security can impact ecological security.
National Security Advisor
The national security advisor is the senior official of the national security Council (NSC) of India and the chief advisor to the prime minister of India on national and international security policy.
Ajit Doval is the current NSA who is now one of the most powerful bureaucrats in India.
National Security Council (NSC)
The national security Council of India is an executive government agency tasked with advising the prime minister’s office on a matter of national security and strategic interest. It was established by the former prime minister of India Atal Bihari Vajpayee on 19 November 1998, with Brajesh Mishra as the first National Security Advisor. Prior to the formation of the NSC, these activities were overseen by the Principal Secretary to the preceding Prime Minister.
National Security Laws in India
India’s security laws were not restricted to three or four laws, it has a series of laws which had the objective of national security and to safeguard the national interest. But the majority of these laws are Unchecked and have unregulated powers that negatively impact the rights of the citizens. These laws were also called as exception laws or a necessary evil.
Soon after the independence, the Constitution was drafted for securing the rights and protecting the citizens. But there was one law in making which abolishes the rights of the citizens.
1) Preventive detention Act 1950 – Before independence Britishers were using statures of preventive detention for establishing their control. But after independence, India suffering from many problems like communal violence which creates an internal disturbance. For securing the territory, the Constitution, and securing the rights of people preventive detention act was established. In Parliament, PDA was introduced by Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel and he said that he spent many sleepless nights thinking about this bill.
The preventive detention act is a law which authorities the government to detain any individual without any charge for a period of one year.
The objective is to control the communal violence at that time, but it is a temporary law that has a sunset clause and it expires in 1969.
2) Maintenance of internal security act 1971-1977 – Just after the expiry of PDA in 1969, the new act was passed MISA (1971). The majority powers of the preventive detention act were included in the MISA. The objective of this act is to impose restrictions on the persons who were detained. In 1975, the imposition of emergency many people were detained without having trail rights or safeguards.
Any person who comes in opposition with the government were detained under this act. In 1977 this act was abolished.
3) Armed forces special powers act (1958)
In 1957- 1958 there was a Separatist movement in Nagaland which causes the violence and the situation was out of control on the hands of the state to stop the violence in North-eastern states, ASPA was introduced in which armed forces were deployed in disturbed areas to maintain the public order.
Section 3 of ASPA gives powers to the government to declare any part of the country as a disturbed area. And gives powers to the armed forces to use their powers in disturbed areas.
4) National Security Act 1980 – It is the reflection of PDA and MISA. In recent times in the period of lockdown four people got arrested under the NSA charges because they were throwing stones on to the health workers. As in PDA, it gives the power to detain or contain in order to prevent future crimes.
In NSA it gives powers to the central and state government to arrest any person in order to establish national security or national interest. The maximum period of confinement in the NSA is 12 months.
In NSA, if anyone is detained he or she is denied of his or her basic rights like right to be informed and legal aid.
5) Terrorist and disruptive activities act (1985-1995) – To control separatist activities and especially terrorist activities in Punjab. It overrides the provisions of the criminal procedure code and the Constitution.
* Many new criminal offenses were made.
* Increment in the powers of police officers.
* Reduced the safeguards of the arrested person.
If anyone gives confession in front of the police it was considered Admissible in the court. Due to this, the cases of abuse and torture have been raised.
So after this, the sunset clause of this act has been used and in 1995 this act has lapsed.
6) Prevention of terrorism act 2001 – In this act, any suspect can be detained for six months. The objective of this act is the same as of TADA. And the problems which were in the TADA were also present in this act like excessive powers of police, evidence admissible, etc.
Allegation on the POTA is that political parties fulfilling their vendetta misusing the power of POTA. So using the sunset clause of this act POTA was lapsed.
7) National investigation agency act (2008 & 2019 amendment) – After the Mumbai terror attack, the NIA bill was passed in 2008 for creating a central agency to look into the matter of terror attack in the country. This agency was created to look into the matters which disturbed the sovereignty, integrity, and security of the state and also against atomic and nuclear facilities.
The recent amendment included some effects into the act:-
Human trafficking, offenses related to counterfeit currency or banknotes, manufacturing and sale of Prohibited arms, cyber terrorism, and offenses under the explosive substance act 1908.
8) Unlawful Activities and prevention act (1967) – Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act is an Indian law aimed at effective prevention of unlawful activities associations in India. Its main objective was to make powers available for dealing with activities directed against the integrity and sovereignty of India.
Latest Amendment for 2019: The Act altered Sec 35, 36, and provided power to the government to declare the individual as a terrorist under Schedule IV of the Act. It also provided power to DG of NIA for the seizure of property in sec 25 and investigation by the rank of an inspector under sec 43.
Many acts and laws were passed earlier to tackle the problems of that time. But after this many acts were lapsed by the sunset clause because they were irrelevant and now endangers or threatens the rights of the citizens. If issues such as these were not managed effectively, national security policies and actions may become ineffective and counterproductive.
- Internship Opportunity: Chair on Consumer Law & Practice, NLSIU Bangalore: Apply Now!
- Internship Opportunity: Researching Reality Internship 2021 at Centre for Civil Society: Apply by 10 May 2021
- ONLINE ARTICLE WRITING COMPETITION BY LEX REPOSITORY: Register by 19 May 2021
- Law Audience’s: 6th National Online Essay Writing Competition 2021: Register by 26 April 2021
- CALL FOR INTERNS: SCHOOL OF IPR AND COMMERCIAL LAWS: Apply by 30 April 2021
- Internship Opportunity: Stambh Virtual Recruitment cum Internship 2021: Apply Now!
- Internship Opportunity: World Bank Legal Internship Program: Apply by April, 30, 2021
- MUN, VIT Pune: 7-8-9 May 2021: Register Now!
- Job Opportunity: Privacy & Right to Information Fellow at Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF): Apply Now
- Internship Opportunity at PRS Legislative Research [May & June]: Applications Open
- National Webinar on Cryptocurrency in South Asia by SLS, Hyderabad, April 16, 2021: Register by April 14, 2021
- Call for Proposal: Regional Research on Climate Change Displacement and Right to Education by UNESCO: Submit by April 12, 2021
- CLAT-Peeps! (8)
- Conferences and Seminars (69)
- Course and Workshops (38)
- Debates (13)
- Eassy Competitions (22)
- Fellowships & Scholarships (11)
- Guest Blogs (3)
- important (18)
- Internships and Jobs (209)
- interviews (7)
- moot court (34)
- Opportuintes (137)
- opportunity (443)
- other services (1)
- others (1)
- Our Blog (530)
- Administrative Law (10)
- ADR (4)
- Case Analysis (101)
- Company law (34)
- Constitutional Law (68)
- Consumer Protection Act (5)
- Contract Law (44)
- CPC (5)
- Criminal Law (68)
- Cyber Law (8)
- Environmental Laws (15)
- Evidence Act (17)
- General (70)
- International law (12)
- IPR (2)
- Jurisprudence (3)
- Partnership Act (2)
- personal law (30)
- Taxation (6)
- Tort (49)
- Top Stories (118)
- Uncategorized (214)