This case analysis is writte by Akshat Mehta, a student of the Institute of Law, Nirma University, Ahmedabad. In this case, he has tried to show how the concept of ‘Strict Liability’ is interpreted in certain conditions depending upon the place and circumstances.
INTRODUCTION
Any person could not be made strictly liable if his/her act is in the direction of ‘Collective paramount Interest’ or is benefiting the public at large and is the interest of the public policy.
Equivalent Citation
(1974) 1 I.A. 364 (P.C.)
Bench
Sir R.P. Collier, Sir J.W. Colvile, Sir L Peel and Sir B. Peacock
Decided On
3 July 1874
Court
Calcutta High Court
Relevant Laws
Strict Liability and Exception of ‘Vis Major/Act of God’
Facts of the Case
The tanks were used to store water for the purposes of irrigation and other agricultural related activities. The district was situated in the hilly areas and tanks were used for storing huge quantity of water since time immemorial and also these are the absolute necessity for the purpose of cultivation also such practice was followed throughout India and particularly in those hilly districts and in Zamindari of Karvetinagaram as it was lawful and governed by custom and usage. Water stored in the tanks is the primary and only source of living and farming for the ryots living in those areas.
On one such instance bulky water stored in those tanks busted and escaped thereby damaging the appellant property and destroying three bridges of the railway. Railway Company brought the suit against the defendant for the recovery of damages suffered by the company.
The defendant (Zamindar) contended that the injuries caused was not due to his negligence but it is an effect ‘Vis Major/Act of God’ and he should be absolved from all the liabilities aroused due to the act of God.
Issues Before the Court
1. Whether the defendant acted negligently in procuring and managing the water in the tanks or it comes under ‘Vis major/Act of God’?
2. Whether the defendant (Zamindar) is liable to pay any sought of compensation to the plaintiff’s sustained by them due to the bursting of the tanks?
Ratio of the Court
The court read the present case in consonance with Vaughan v. Taff Vale Railway Company, Jones v. The Festiniog Railway Company, Rylands v. Fletcher and Withers v. The North Kent Railway Company.
High Court had given its reasoning on the basis of two grounds:
1. The water stored in the tanks is used by all the ryots of the area. Hence it is in the benefit of the society and catering to the needs of ‘Paramount Collective Interest’. In this regard, the court stated that “The existence of these tanks is absolutely necessary, not only for the beneficial enjoyment of the defendant’s land, but for the sustenance of thousands of his ryots.” Therefore it is inequitable if liability is imposed on the owner of the land where water tanks were situated; rather greater obligation could be created to take care of any escape of such things which could potentially harm the neighbors.
2. Particularly in regards to the Indian conditions the water is required to be stored in larger quantities. Hence, it falls under the necessity rather and the exception to the doctrine of ‘Strict Liability’ optimistically applies here. Also, the condition of non-natural use of land varies from place to place and situation to situation.
Decision of the Court
Hence Court held that here, in this case, the exception to the rule of ‘Strict Liability’ applies and the defendant couldn’t be directed to pay the compensation to the appellants because he had taken all reasonable precautions while storing water in the tanks. The High Court dismissed the appeal of the appellants i.e. Railway Company.
Latest Posts
- CCLP and NLU Jodhpur, is pleased to invite submission of Indian Competition Law Review(“ICLR”)
- 7th SGTU National Moot Court Competition 2023 in Collaboration with Competition Commission of India [OCT 27-29, GURUGRAM]: Register by 28th September 2023.
- Legal Take on Gender Stereotypes in Indian Society
- Amendment of Article 370 – A Constitutional History
- The impact of India’s Right to Information Act, 2005
- Viability of Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act in the Present Commercial Context
- Call for Papers – National Virtual Seminar on ‘Constitutionalism in Contemporary Times | NLUJ
- Job Opportunity at JSA
- Job Opportunity at Upscale Legal, New Delhi
- Unauthorized Alienation and its Consequences in the Coparcenary Property
- Job Opportunity at Appellate Tribunal New Delhi
- Assessment Internship Opportunity at Jain & Partners
- CLAT-Peeps! (10)
- Current Affairs (2)
- competitions (132)
- Conferences and Seminars (200)
- Course and Workshops (107)
- Debates (46)
- Eassy Competitions (69)
- Fellowships & Scholarships (56)
- Guest Blogs (6)
- important (28)
- Internships and Jobs (2,292)
- interviews (8)
- moot court (179)
- Opportuintes (2,704)
- Job Opportunity (1,169)
- opportunity (2,532)
- Call for papers (475)
- Quizes,fests and others (298)
- Work Opportunity (811)
- Our Blog (1,048)
- Administrative Law (17)
- ADR (13)
- Arms Act (2)
- Case Analysis (205)
- Company law (36)
- Constitutional Law (142)
- Consumer Protection Act (17)
- Contract Law (62)
- CPC (10)
- Criminal Law (140)
- Cyber Law (13)
- Environmental Laws (30)
- Evidence Act (20)
- Family Law (12)
- General (205)
- International Humanitarian Law (8)
- International law (23)
- IPR (10)
- Jurisprudence (13)
- labor laws (7)
- Maritime Laws (1)
- Partnership Act (2)
- personal law (33)
- Taxation (10)
- Tort (64)
- Transfer of Property (2)
- Our Services (11)
- career advice (2)
- others (6)
- Top Stories (524)
- Uncategorized (719)
Archives
- September 2023
- August 2023
- July 2023
- June 2023
- May 2023
- April 2023
- March 2023
- February 2023
- January 2023
- December 2022
- November 2022
- October 2022
- September 2022
- August 2022
- July 2022
- June 2022
- May 2022
- April 2022
- March 2022
- February 2022
- January 2022
- December 2021
- November 2021
- October 2021
- September 2021
- August 2021
- July 2021
- June 2021
- May 2021
- April 2021
- March 2021
- February 2021
- January 2021
- December 2020
- November 2020
- October 2020
- September 2020
- August 2020
- July 2020
- June 2020
- May 2020
- April 2020
- February 2020
- January 2020
- November 2019