The present case analysis has been done by Vanshika Arora.
Case Number
Appeal (civil) 1382 of 2002
Equivalent Citation
2002 (1) RAJ 381 (SC)
Bench:
Hon’ble Justice GB Pattanaik, Hon’ble Justice SN Phukan, Hon’ble Justice SN Varivan
Date of Judgment:
20th February 2002
Relevant Act
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1966
Relevant Sections
Sections 4, 5, 10, 11, 16, 34
Facts of the Case
The Appellant and Respondent had a family dispute over business and properties. For which two arbitrators were hired (Mr. Pramod Kumar Khaitan, and Mr.Sardul Singh Jain). An award was passed by the two arbitrators on 6th October 1996. On 22nd December 1997, the first respondent filed an application in Calcutta High Court for setting aside the award. The contention was that, under Section 10 of The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1966, an even number of arbitrators cannot be present. Since in the present matter, two arbitrators were present, it was contended that arbitration was void and invalid. On the same line of reasoning, it was also contended that the award is henceforth also void and invalid. A single judge of the Calcutta HC set aside the award on 17th November 1998, subsequently, an appeal dated 18th May 2000 was also dismissed. Thereon, the matter was bought before the SC.
Issues before the Court
Whether Section10 is a non-derogable provision in Arbitration? Whether a mandatory provision of the Act can be waived by the parties?
Ratio Decidendi
The appellant contended that Section 10 is a mandatory provision of the Act. In the present matter, the Arbitral tribunal was not validly constituted, hence it should be void and invalid. Moreover, if the constitution of the arbitrators is invalid, it should also render the award void. The appellant also contended that Section 16 does not provide for any challenge of the constitution of the Arbitration Tribunal. Therefore, an invalidly constituted tribunal deems lack of jurisdiction. It was also contended that in the case of an even number of arbitrators, they may have conflicting opinions, which may result in a fresh arbitration altogether. This could be a waste of time and energy for both parties, and an infringement of public policy. Hence, Section 10 should be considered a non-derogable provision. In the court’s opinion, that the question, whether Section 10 is non-derogable would depend on whether a party has a right to object to the composition of the arbitral tribunal, and at what stage.
The decision of the Court
The court held the contention of Section 10 is a non-derogable provision, unacceptable. Since it cannot be said that an arbitration agreement becomes invalid when only two arbitrators are appointed. In such a case, Section 11(3), the two arbitrators can appoint a third one. The court held that an appointment of the third arbitrator can be done at a later stage, i.e when the two differ, and need not be mandatorily done at the initial stages of the agreement. Further, the court held that an award can only be set aside under the provisions of Sections 12, 13, 16, and 34. An award cannot be set aside if the composition of the arbitral tribunal and proceedings are in accordance with the agreement between the parties. The right to challenge an award, in case tribunal and proceedings are not in accordance, is also restricted. In a sense that, even if the composition of the arbitral tribunal or the arbitral procedure is not in accordance with the agreement of the parties but if such composition or procedure is in accordance with the provisions of the Act, then the party cannot challenge the award.
LATEST POSTS
- Job opportunity at EXO Edge, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
- Internship opportunity at Vishwas Advisors, Kalyan, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
- Internship opportunity at Kulfi Collective, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!
- Job opportunity at The Neotia University, Diamond Harbour, West Bengal, India: Apply Now !!
- Job opportunity at Morgan Stanley, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at VISA INTELLIGENCE CONSULTANCY LLP, New Delhi, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at Amazon Web Services (AWS), Gurugram, Haryana, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at Stelcore Management Services Private Limited, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at Zscaler, Sahibzada Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at Irish Expert, Delhi, India: Apply Now!!
- Job opportunity at UnitedLex · Gurgaon, Haryana, India: Apply Now!
- Internship opportunity at Vineforce · Nabha, Punjab, India: Apply Now!!
- Administrative Law
- ADR
- Arms Act
- Call for papers
- career advice
- Case Analysis
- CLAT-Peeps!
- Company law
- competitions
- Conferences and Seminars
- Constitutional Law
- Consumer Protection Act
- Contract Law
- Course and Workshops
- CPC
- Criminal Law
- Current Affairs
- Cyber Law
- Debates
- Eassy Competitions
- Environmental Laws
- Evidence Act
- Family Law
- Fellowships & Scholarships
- General
- Guest Blogs
- important
- International Humanitarian Law
- International law
- Internships and Jobs
- interviews
- IPR
- Job Opportunity
- Jurisprudence
- labor laws
- Maritime Laws
- moot court
- Opportuintes
- opportunity
- others
- Our Blog
- Our Services
- Partnership Act
- personal law
- Quizes,fests and others
- Taxation
- Top Stories
- Tort
- Transfer of Property
- Uncategorized
- Webinar
- Work Opportunity
ARCHIVES
- November 2023 (26)
- October 2023 (1)
- September 2023 (5)
- August 2023 (2)
- July 2023 (25)
- June 2023 (23)
- May 2023 (40)
- April 2023 (136)
- March 2023 (124)
- February 2023 (138)
- January 2023 (61)
- December 2022 (39)
- November 2022 (103)
- October 2022 (178)
- September 2022 (342)
- August 2022 (240)
- July 2022 (273)
- June 2022 (196)
- May 2022 (27)
- April 2022 (99)
- March 2022 (190)
- February 2022 (196)
- January 2022 (193)
- December 2021 (152)
- November 2021 (203)
- October 2021 (189)
- September 2021 (177)
- August 2021 (192)
- July 2021 (393)
- June 2021 (293)
- May 2021 (179)
- April 2021 (61)
- March 2021 (46)
- February 2021 (56)
- January 2021 (63)
- December 2020 (86)
- November 2020 (94)
- October 2020 (146)
- September 2020 (220)
- August 2020 (173)
- July 2020 (165)
- June 2020 (119)
- May 2020 (136)
- April 2020 (7)
- February 2020 (37)
- January 2020 (3)
- November 2019 (1)