Introduction

The law of the sea is the foundation for the crucial marine trade that drives our economy which formalizes the key norms of freedom of passage for national security. It allows India to protect, manage, and use the resources of our bordering waters and continental shelf for the sake of the environment and the economy. For centuries, the sea was sole of importance to humanity as a source of food and continue exploiting the norms of the sea and its habitat. After the introduction of legislation such as the United Nations Convention of the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), the water bodies have been protected worldwide to secure a chance for future generations to use those water bodies for their very existence. So, why do we need to know about the Law of the sea? What importance does it possess?

As a resident of this planet, people should be aware of the territorial sea’s extent, which administers coastal fish populations, the laws governing straits passage, and a slew of other rules that allow the seas to function harmoniously. We just do not understand the basic laws if some governments claim five nautical miles for their territorial sea and others claim three hundred nautical miles. The rule of law, however, is much more important since it acts as a check on authority.

UNCLOS

The international community implemented a holistic framework for legal control of the seas with the ratification of the United Nations Convention on the Legislation of the Sea (UNCLOS) in 1982, which has developed into a formidable body of law over time. UNCLOS unifies the four Geneva Conventions into a single instrument. This treaty unified existing international law and established new maritime law and organizations. In terms of substance, however, it goes much further than the four. The “new” law of the sea, for example, expands the rights of coastal governments in both descriptive and analytical aspects, in some cases significantly.

  • The International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS) was formed by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea in 1982 as an independent legal authority. It has jurisdiction over any dispute arising out of the Convention’s interpretation or application, as well as those topics expressly provided for in any other agreement conferring jurisdiction on the Tribunal.
  • The UNCLOS also has a separate legal body known as the United Nations Division for Ocean Affairs and the Law of the Sea (UNDOALOS) which provides nations and global institutions a variety of legal and technical services relevant to the UNCLOS, such as information and assistance as well as conducting research and compiling studies for proper implementation,

Objectives:

  1. To encourage the peaceful usage of the oceans and seas.
  2. To make international communication easier.
  3. To make ocean resources fairer and more efficient to use.
  4. The aquatic ecosystem must be protected and preserved.
  5. The goal is to increase maritime safety.

Maritime Areas under UNCLOS

  1. Territorial Sea
    A coastal State’s territorial sea is limited to 12 nautical miles from its baseline. The coastal State has complete authority over the air space above the sea, as well as the seabed and subsoil, within this zone. An innocent passage is a name given to this form of territorial transit by foreign ships. The right to innocent passage can, however, be prohibited if the maritime state’s security is jeopardized. However, the coastal state has certain obligations, such as Article 21(1) – (4) of UNCLOS, Constitution requires the coastal state to implement relevant laws protecting the right to innocent passage. That is to say, the coastal state has the responsibility to safeguard the safety of innocent passage under Article 22(1) of UNCLOS.
    Innocent Passage (Article 17 of UNCLOS) – Passage is legal as long as it does not jeopardize the coastal state’s peace, good order, or security. To put it another way, the vessel exercising its right of an innocent passage should not represent a substantial and intolerable threat to the coastal state.
  2. Continuous Zone
    The contiguous zone Article 33 of UNCLOS is the area of the sea beyond and adjacent to a coastal state’s territorial sea. It may not exceed the breadth of the territorial sea, which is estimated at 24 miles. Contiguous zones provide the coastal state with an extra-jurisdictional territory for restricted reasons. The authority that a coastal state has over this region is confined to the prohibition of conduct that might violate its customs, fiscal, and immigration regulations. It can also intervene if any action in the adjacent zone jeopardizes territorial norms.
  3. Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)
    Exclusive Economic Zone or Patrimonial Sea (Article 55 of UNCLOS) is a territory outside and near to the territorial sea that is subject to the legal system, under which the coastal State’s rights and jurisdiction, as well as the rights and freedoms of other States, are controlled by the provisions relating of this Convention. The EEZ is a belt of the sea next to the shore that stretches up to 200 miles from the territorial sea’s baselines.
  4. High Seas
    The section of the sea that is not included in the exclusive economic zone, territorial sea, internal waters of a coastal state, or archipelagic waters of an archipelagic state is known as the high seas (Article 87 of UNCLOS). All governments have access to the high seas for the purposes of navigation, overflight, artificial island construction, fishing, and scientific study. The high seas are designated for peaceful international navigation. Slavery, piracy, ship confiscation, illicit drugs trafficking, and unlawful broadcasting have all been prohibited by legislation.
  5. Continental Shelf
    The continental shelf [Article 76(1) of UNCLOS] is defined as a region whose outer border is not more than 350 nautical miles from the baseline or 100 nautical miles from the isobath at 2500 meters. In this area, the coastal state has exclusive rights to explore and develop its natural resources. The state also has sole authority to permit and control any shelf drilling for whatever reason.

Concluding Observations

After analyzing the above study, it can be concluded that the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea has provided the strategical framework to govern the International Law of the Sea. It can be considered that the UNCLOS has comprehensively described the extent to which a state’s sovereignty extends to the sea’s edge for a peaceful usage of the water bodies for all nations which clearly eliminates the idea of conflicts between them.

Written by Hemant Bohra student at School of Law, Lovely Professional University, Punjab.

About Shraff Legal, Advocates

Shraff Legal, Advocates is a law firm practicing in areas like Taxation and animal rights Law. They have well enriched litigation practice and team to represent clients before Supreme Court, High Courts, Tribunals, Authority for Advance Rulings & other tax courts.

Address: Unit No. 202, Marry Appts, 29A, S End Park Rd, Kolkata, West Bengal 700029, India

Job Description

Assistance in Drafting writ petitions, Research work, appearance before High Courts in tax matters with focus on GST.

Eligibility

Law Graduate with atleast one year experience in tax matters particularly GST.

Location

Kolkata, West Bengal (in person)

Number of Associates Required

2 (two)

How to Apply?

  • E-mail your resume to hr.shrafflegal@gmail.com
  • An interview shall be conducted prior to selection as an Associate at Shraff legal advocates.

Link for more details

https://in.linkedin.com/in/vinay-shraff-1b2b873

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

Applications are invited from eligible candidates for the Gen B Campus Ambassador Program by Basis.

If you’ve always dreamed of working on an impactful product that caters to women’s needs – specifically their financial and investment needs, then the Gen B Campus Ambassador program is the right place for you. It’s literally a ‘gold’en opportunity because you get to join BASIS and be a part of the revolution!

About Basis 

Basis is India’s financial services destination for women, powered by education and community. No matter which step you’re at in your financial journey, Basis helps you learn and keeps you informed about your options when it comes to your finances.

So that you can make informed decisions about what to do with your money, and how to grow it. You also get access to a rich library of tailor-made content, curated financial recommendations, resources that help you set and plan financial goals, and most importantly — a strong community of women such as yourself, that you can count on.

About the Gen B Campus Ambassador Program

It’s time to unleash your potential with the Gen B Campus Ambassador program, by Basis. Join them as they demystify the world of finance for young women. But it’s not solely about building a community, but also an opportunity for you to lead and implement your learnings on the job, on campus.

Become a part of the program virtually. Join from any location and work within the fascinating space of fintech, all while pursuing your current degrees. Boost your CV, and above all, as a Gen B member, create your own network for financial well-being and learn how to manage your personal finances. 

Perks 

  • Lead your campus’ program and work with them to innovate as they strive for success. 
  • Publish content on the Basis app and other Basis platforms. 
  • Get mentored by Basis founders and team members who are alumni of Ivy League institutions like Wharton, Harvard, and other global leaders,  on a quarterly basis.
  • Feature on the Basis website and app as a key part of the exclusive GenB Club. 
  • Create your own network for financial well-being and become an expert when it comes to handling personal finance.
  • Boost your CV with an E- Certificate.

And also:

  • You get exclusive BASIS merchandise, on successful completion of the program.
  • AND you learn how to manage your stipend, gifts, savings, and first salaries even better.

Roles and Responsibilities

Assist Basis by organizing conversations with the women on your campuses. They value creativity and impactful work, which is why they want to give you the freedom to frame the structure of this event, as you please — be it a webinar, a Q&A, a fun quiz, or a contest maybe. You choose! 

Work with them to create our monthly content-worthy newsletter, and you even get to  publish your work, on the space. 

Eligibility

  • Young women who are currently studying and have always wanted to work towards bringing about change in the way women approach investing.
  • They would prefer students who have been actively involved in college activities but are also open to anyone who is committed to working for the cause. 
  • Result-driven individuals, high energy leaders who possess strong communication and presentation skills are our kind of people 
  • Those who are willing to learn and grow and are able to commit to at least 10 hours per month to the Gen B Campus Ambassador program. 

How to Apply?

Interested applicants can apply for the Gen B Campus Ambassador program through this link.

Tenure

  • The tenure of the candidates will be based on their performance review during the 30 days mandatory probation period.
  • You are required to stay associated with Basis for a minimum of six months and a maximum of a lifetime.

Contact 

Email: genb@getbasis.co

Link for more details

https://www.noticebard.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Brochure-1-compressed.pdf

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

About the opportunity

Advocate Vikas Pathak (Empanelled Lawyer for Enforcement Directorate) is inviting Application for an offline internship.

About the internship

This internship will provide the selected candidates an opportunity to attend the Court hearings before the PMLA Authority, PMLA Appellate Tribunal, Various District Courts, and the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, on a daily basis. The selected candidates shall also be involved in preparing legal briefs of case files, Briefing the Senior Counsels, legal research on various law propositions, and also Drafting various applications/legal opinions, Legal Documents.

Eligibility

The Candidates are expected to be diligent and have strong communication skills.

Mode of internship:

Offline

Internship Period

1 month

No. Of Interns Required

Three (3)

(This Internship shall be subject to a Personal Interaction which shall be intimated shortly after the preliminary screening round)

Procedure to apply

Interested candidates can apply at kanikakapoor.k29@gmail.com.

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

About Anand Law College

Anand Law College is a legal establishment recognized by the Bar Council of India, New Delhi since 1964 and is motivated by highly enthusiastic professionals under the guidance and supervision of the great visionary Late Dr. Gordhanbhai Shanabhai Patel (Vakil Saheb).

The college is managed by Shri Ramkrishna Seva Mandal, Anand and has been rendered an authenticity for permanent recognition to offer various Law Programmes. Its affiliation is with Sardar Patel University, Vallabh Vidyanagar.

About Anand College of Legal Studies

Anand College of Legal Studies is a legal institution recognized by the Bar Council of India, New Delhi since 2016. College is managed by Shri Ramkrishna Seva Mandal, Anand and has been granted permanent recognition to offer various Law programs. It is affiliated to Sardar Patel University, Vallabh Vidyanagar. ACLS is one of the best law colleges in Gujarat which provides various law courses.

Theme

Global Landscape of Women’s Empowerment in Today’s Era

Sub-theme

  • Empowering Women, Empowering Humanity.
  • Gender Equality and the Millennium Development Goals.
  • Women’s Empowerment: Bringing a Change in the Attitude of Society.
  • World vision for women empowerment.
  • Social and Political dimensions of the issue of Women Empowerment in India.
  • Women Empowerment: The key to achieve Social & Economic growth of the country as well as globe.
  • Role of Social legislation, Government policies and enactments to achieve women empowerment.
  • Biased attitude of society: a major hurdle in achieving women empowerment.
  • Role of constitution and Judiciary in Empowering Women in India.
  • Empower a woman to empower the next generation globally.
  • Crimes against women globally: a spot on gender equality and women empowerment.
  • Challenges and hurdles in the journey of women empowerment and suggested measures to overcome these hurdles.
  • International women’s Day- its relevance in the Indian Perspective.

Above themes are only illustrative but not exhaustive. The paper presenters may select the related topic covered under the main theme.

Eligibility

Seminar papers are invited from faculties, lawyers, social activists, research scholars and students on any sub thematic areas or it could be submitted on the main theme in general.

Submission Procedure

The registration link

https://forms.gle/QFA684GfhT8rswym8

Research paper presenter is expected to apply research skill and use appropriate research methodology. It is necessary that every paper is confined to thematic or sub-themes of seminar. It should have proper research questions and also suggest the outcomes of research with the findings. Paper should not contain more than 4000 words.

It must be typed in Times New Roman Font Size 12 on A4 size paper with 1“ margin on all sides with 1.5 line spacing using MS Word. Submission of empirical research paper is appreciated, but researcher is expected to submit analysis of substantive data and sample report.
Kindly send your abstract or full paper soft copy/electronic form only on following

E-mail ID: anandlawcollege9999@gmail.com

Every paper presenter is required to submit an abstract of 350 words with keywords stating the statement of problem, research questions, and methodology applied in the paper with
major expected findings.

Fee Details

  • Faculties, Lawyers, Social Activists: Rs. 300/-
  • Research Scholars: Rs. 200/-
  • Students: Rs. 150/-

Important Dates

  • Registration Close: 25/02/2022
  • Submission of Abstract and full paper submission: 4/3/2022
  • Confirmation: 5/3/2022

Contact details

Ranvirsinh Mahida: 9879859559

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

About the Delhivery

Delhivery provided supply chain solutions to a diverse base of over 21000 active customers such as e-commerce marketplaces, direct-to-consumer e-tailers and enterprises and SMEs across several verticals such as FMCG, consumer durables, consumer electronics, lifestyle, retail, automotive and manufacturing.

About the opportunity

Delhivery is looking for a lawyer with up to 3 years PQE for its in-house legal team. The position is based out of Gurugram and will involve a mix of corporate and litigation work.

Requirement

Candidates with both corporate and litigation experience will be preferred. However, candidates with only litigation or corporate experience may be considered if they are open to learning and working on both.

Procedure to apply

Interested applicants to share their CVs at: Bharat.singhsandhu@delhivery.com.

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

About Vishwakarma University

Vishwakarma University (VU) is a natural offshoot of the Vishwakarma Group of Institutions’ educational legacy spanning more than 35 years. The University has been established as a State Private University through Maharashtra Government Act in the year 2017. Being UGC approved, VU is authorized to design and implement its curriculum, conduct examinations, award degrees.

Concept Note of the Event

The United Nation Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) proclaimed by the United Nations General Assembly in Paris on 10th December 1948 set the common standard of achieving fundamental human rights, inclusive of all people and nations.

The preamble and the articles of UDHR recognise and articulate the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family and worth of the human person and in the equal rights of men and women in society.

Agenda 5 of The Sustainable Development Goals 2030 (SDG) targets “Gender Equality” not only as a fundamental human right, but a necessary foundation for a peaceful, prosperous and sustainable world. Despite the introduction of women supportive laws in some countries, discriminatory laws and social norms remain pervasive, women continue to be under-represented at all levels of political leadership, and 1 in 5 women and girls between the ages of 15 and 49 report experiencing physical or sexual violence by an intimate partner within 12 months. Yet, 49 countries have no laws that specifically protect women from such violence.

Intimate Partner Violence (IPV), encompassing “Domestic Abuse” can take a number of forms, including physical, verbal, emotional, economic and sexual abuse that transcends socioeconomic, religious and cultural groups and spans from online trolling to domestic violence. IPV is typically manifested as a pattern of abusive behaviour toward an intimate partner in a dating or family relationship, where the abuser exerts power and control over the victim. Incidents are rarely isolated, and usually escalate in frequency and severity. Domestic abuse may culminate in serious physical injury or death. The overwhelming global burden of IPV is borne by women.

World Health Organisation (‘WHO”) has also taken cognisance of the fact that Intimate Partner Violence is one of the most common forms of violence against women and includes physical, sexual, and emotional abuse and controlling behaviours by an intimate partner.

It is imperative that in the lens of Law, IPV including Domestic Abuse to be considered beyond a conventional ‘marital argument’ or a ‘private matter, best left to the couple to resolve between themselves and their families. Laws specifically need to address the intricate intertwined issues within the expansive contours of IPV and provide a viable legal and enforceable platform to Women seeking justice against IPV.

Call for Papers

The Organizing Committee welcomes original and unpublished papers on the followingsub-themes:

  1. What constitutes Abusive Intimate Relationship?
  2. Domestic Violence: Sociological, Psychological, and Legal Aspects
  3. Addressing Gender equality to meet the Sustainable Development Goals, 2030
  4. Viewing Abusive Relationships through the Judicial Lens in various jurisdictions
  5. Domestic violence in the context of Socio-demographic spectrum involving the Elderly, Women, Children, Men, Homosexual Couples.
  6. Mitigating Abusive Relationships and Domestic Violence
  7. Law Enforcement and Justice related to Abusive Intimate Relationship. The Administrative Sanctioning System and Criminal Justice System related to Domestic Violence Cases
  8. Rehabilitation of Victims of Domestic Violence and Abusive Intimate Relationship
  9. The role of Social and Feminist movements
  10. Role of Media and Representation of abusive relations

Eligibility

  • Academicians, Researchers, and Policymakers
  • Professionals and Government Officials.
  • Human Rights Activists and Non-Governmental Organisations

Paper Submission Procedure

  • The title of the paper should be followed by Name, Designation, Name of the Organization/University/Institution and Email address. It is mandatory to mention Email address, as all future correspondence will be through it.
  • The work submitted shall be the original and unpublished work of the author(s)
  • Word Limit (Inclusive of Footnotes): 4000-6000 Words
  • Citation: The Citation style should be in consonance with 19th Edition Bluebook.
  • The body of the paper shall be: Font: Times New Roman, Font Size: 12, Line Spacing: 1.5
  • Citations Font: Times New Roman, Font Size: 10 and Line Spacing: 1
  • Headings should be Bold, in Capitals
  • Note: Selected Papers will be published in an Edited Book with ISBN number.

Abstract Submission Procedure

Abstract (of about 250 words) should be sent as an attachment in a word file. Abstracts will be peer-reviewed before they are accepted.
The following information, in the given format, should be sent along with the Abstract:

  • Name of the Participant,
  • Official Designation/Institution Details,
  • Address and E-mail ID,
  • Title of Abstract

Submit your abstract to events.law@vupune.ac.in

Fee Details

There are No Registration charges for participation and paper presentation. However, registration for the event is mandatory.

For registration, click here: https://forms.gle/wuAwAk3LSz6MAhXc9

Important Dates

  1. Registration starts on: 1st February 2022
  2. Last Date for Abstract Submission: 15th February 2022
  3. Communication for acceptance of Abstract: 17th February 2022
  4. Last Date of Registration for Paper Presentation: 20th February 2022
  5. Last Date for Full Paper Submission: 1st March 2022
  6. Last Date of Registration for Participation: 5th March 2022
  7. Date of Conference: 7th and 8th March 2022

Contact details

Mail at: events.law@vupune.ac.in

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

Abstract – The historical foundations of Indian experiences and conceptions of property and wealth are considerably different from those of Western countries. The current property system, as we know it, sprang from unique events in Europe throughout the 17th and 18th centuries, and hence its lessons were not generally applicable. The concept of property rights is another economic sector where the solution is both complex and crucial. The author attempts to determine the motivation behind this unfortunate move.

INTRODUCTION

Property rights are not recognized as basic rights in the Indian Constitution. The 44th amendment, passed in 1977, made the right to acquire, keep, and dispose of property no longer a basic right. However, Article 300 (A) was added to another section of the Constitution to state that no one’s property may be taken away unless by law. As a result, the basic right to property has been replaced with a statutory right to property.

Article 19 (1) (f)
By providing an absolute basic right to property, the Indian constitution endeavored to reconcile the right to property with the right to recompense for its acquisition, balancing it with reasonable restrictions, and adding a further fundamental right of compensation if the properties are acquired by the state. Article 19(1) (f), which was balanced by Article 19(5) and the compensation article in Article 31, demonstrated this. When the state discovered that an absolute right to property and people’s ambitions were not the same, the legislature was obliged to change the constitution to make the aforementioned right to property subject to social welfare.

DOCTRINE OF EMINENT DOMAIN

This theory allows a sovereign to purchase private land for public use if the utility of the land can be shown beyond a reasonable doubt. In the current setting, this concept resurrects the age-old conflict over state authority vs. individual rights. Here comes the DID (Growth Induced Displacement), which refers to the forcible removal of communities from their homes, often from their ancestral lands, for the sake of economic development, and is considered a violation
of human rights on an international level.

Essential elements of this Doctrine:

  • A piece of property is seized for public use.
  • The seized property has been compensated.

As indicated above, the deleted Article 31 imposed two constraints on Eminent Domain power.

SUPREME COURT’S APPROACH TO THE RIGHT TO PROPERTY

The approach of the Supreme Court regarding the right to property may be separated into two phases:-

  1. The time till the right to property was a fundamental right (pre-1978)
  2. The time after the conversion of the right to property as a constitutional right (post-1978)

Right to Property as Fundamental Right
During this time, the Supreme Court went out of its way to oppose the right to property and the right to accumulate wealth, as well as to hold that, concerning Article 39, the distribution of material resources to better serve the common good and the restriction on wealth concentration, the right to property and the right to accumulate wealth were unconstitutional. The judiciary, on the other hand, is in charge of taming the socialist state’s abuses of the right to property and wealth. During the Liberalisation period, the Supreme Court endeavored to reinterpret the rules
that safeguard the right to property to make the protection genuine rather than illusory and to reduce the claim of wealth distribution.

However, this has been a piecemeal approach, and much more has to be done to restore the constitution’s original balance. This indicates that property acquisition is not just temporal but must also adhere to spiritual rules. Indian ideas understand that while the property can be enjoyed that has not been gained exactly according to the law, it cannot be termed the person’s true property.

Right to Property as Constitutional Right
The backlash against Articles 19 (1) (f) and Article 31 of the Constitution as Fundamental Rights began almost immediately after it was enacted in 1950. Thus, times have changed drastically in recent years. India is no longer viewed solely from the perspective of socialist politicians. It’s India Shining as viewed through the eyes of financial behemoths like the Tatas, Ambanis, and Mahindras, who have an inexplicable passion for capitalism, money, and markets. There’s another point of view. Industrialists and developers are vying for land across the country to establish Special Economic Zones.

Previously, the Supreme Court had defined some basic and unchangeable parameters and features of the Indian state and constitution, such as the country’s democratic form of government, as its basic structure, which could not be changed even by constitutional amendment, in the famous Kesavanand Bharti case of 1973. However, in his decision, Justice H.R. Khanna made a brief remark to the effect that citizens’ fundamental rights may not constitute a fundamental component of the Constitution.

Flaws in the 44th Amendment Act
The amendment was passed without considering the following disadvantages:
a. The close relationship between property and other fundamental rights, which the Janata Party promised to restore;
b. The impact of this change on the legislative power to acquire and requisition property;
and
c. The relationship between state policy directive principles and fundamental rights.

Implications
a. The Right to Property would no longer be a Fundamental Right, but rather a Constitutional Right. Only the High Courts, not the Supreme Court, can now question the legislation that infringes the fundamental right to property.
b. With the repeal of Article 31, the government was no longer obligated to recompense anyone whose land had been taken under the authority of a statute enacted by Parliament.

As of now, it is beyond the scope of my research and understanding to determine whether Proposition (ii), i.e. property deprivation without compensation, is still legally tenable, especially in light of the Supreme Court’s ruling in the Maneka Gandhi case, which stated that every provision of the Constitution must be explained in a fair, just, and reasonable manner. As a result, any law that deprives a person of his property must do so in an explainable manner. It may be claimed that the only legitimate way to deprive someone of their property is to provide them with appropriate recompense. This debate, however, is not entirely relevant to the topic of this article.

CONCLUSION

Personal rights such as the ability to vote, freedom of expression, and personal liberty were once regarded to have a greater position in the hierarchy of values than the right to property. As an outcome, judges are expected to strike down legislation that infringes fundamental rights than those that infringed property rights. However, courts of law have determined that the distinction between the two is illusory and that no one appears to have given any consideration to why property rights are not personal rights. In 1972, the Supreme Court of the United States, which had priorly provided a warm welcome to the difference between property and personal rights and accorded the former a preferred status, laid to rest both the difference and the preferred status of so-called personal liberties or rights by announcing that the dichotomy between property liberties and personal rights is a false one.

Whether the property in conflict is a home, a welfare check, or a savings account, the right to enjoy property without illegal deprivation is an aspect of a personal right, just like the right to travel or the freedom to speak. In reality, the human right to liberty and the personal right to property are fundamentally intertwined. Without the other, neither could have significance.

Written by Hemant Bohra student at School of Law, Lovely Professional University, Punjab.

About the AMUCM Law Society Review

AMUCM Law Society Review is the flagship journal of Aligarh Muslim University Centre Murshidabad, started with the objective of promoting academic research and proselytize debate on contemporary legal issues. The Review is a yearly, double-blind student reviewed and edited journal, focusing on an inter-disciplinary approach towards legal writing. The sphere of the review is not restricted to any particular field of law but is broad enough to include national as well as international socio-legal approach. We are pleased to announce that the Aligarh Muslim University Centre Murshidabad is going to publish a Journal of the Law Society. It aims to provide a platform to the academicians, practitioners, researchers and students to express their experiences and opinions on varied issues of contemporary importance, through their erudite articles and research papers. 

AMUCM Law Society Review 2022 is offering an opportunity to get your insightful writings published in the form of Research Papers, Case Comments, Articles & Essays, and Book/Film Reviews and other such submission for its flagship publication (to be published in the form of a book with ISBN number). 

Submission guidelines

Author(s) are required to submit their abstract and manuscripts at lawsocietyamucm@gmail.com in (.doc) or (.docx) format only. Submissions of the Abstract must be made to the above-mentioned email ID, with the subject line “Abstract Submission for AMUCM Law Society Review 2022.” And before 11:59 PM, 28 th February 2022.The word limit for the Abstract is 250 words. The abstract must indicate key findings on a topic. 

No biographical information or references, including the name(s) of the author(s), affiliation(s), and acknowledgments should be included in the abstract submission.  

A separate cover letter in (.doc) or (.docx) format containing particulars of the author(s) and the submission details is to be sent along with the submission.  

Submissions of Manuscript must be submitted to the above-mentioned email ID, with the subject line “Manuscript Submission for AMUCM Law Society Review 2022.” and before 11:59 PM, 30th March 2022. Similarly, the document containing the cover letter shall be named in the manner ‘Cover letter_ Title of the submission’. 

A cover letter shall include: (1) Title of Submission; (2) Abstract; (3) Name of the Author and Co-Author, if any; (4) Designation; (5) Institutional Affiliation; (6) Contact Information and Address for Correspondence.  

Scholastic uses only footnotes (and not endnotes) as a mode of citation. Submissions must conform to the ILI mode of Citation style. Do not include any pictures or other illustrations in the submission. All the submissions have to be in English.  

A mail confirming the abstract of the manuscript and subsequently its acceptance for publication would be duly conveyed to the author/s through the email id used by the author(s) for correspondence. The submission of the author(s) shall be accepted for publication on the condition that they do not infringe on the copyright or any other rights of any third parties.  

Author(s) shall be responsible for infringement of any law. All submissions will undergo strict online plagiarism check. Special consideration will be placed upon originality, applicability and feasibility of the arguments/ suggestions made in the manuscript the depth of research. 

Submission of a manuscript shall be taken to imply that it is an unpublished work and is not being considered for publication elsewhere. The e-certificate of publication and the free copy of e-journal shall be provided to every selected author via e-mail.

Types of Submission and word limit:  

  • Research Papers: 3,000 to 5,000 words  
  • Case Comments and Legislative Comments: 2,000 to 3,000 words 
  • Articles and Essays: 1,500 to 2,500 words
  • Book/Film Reviews: 1,000 to 2,000 words

Subject Topics: The submission should be on any theme relating to Law. You need to mention it while submitting an email.  

Co-authorship: (up to 2 authors) is permitted.  

Originality: No plagiarism (except the accepted 10%). No copyrighted content. The researched information and the content must not be copied from any other content available on the internet. You shall take the help of enacted laws/Acts/Rules/ commentaries, SC/HC landmark judgments, government websites, new updates on the concerned law/future development or amendments in the Act expected from the government 

Referencing: The source of the information must be mentioned. The source should be genuine and the link should be attached.

Formatting:

Font: Time News Roman
Font Size: 12
Spacing: 1.5
Margin: One inch on all sides
Paper size: A4

Citation style

Must follow the ILI rules of citation.
Citation Font Size: 10
Spacing: 1.0
Citation Font: Times New Roman

Important dates

  • Last Date for Submission of Abstract:- 28 th February 2022  
  • Communication of Acceptance/Rejection of Abstract by:- 5 th March 2022  
  • Last date for Final Submission of Full Paper: 30th March 2022 

Brochure

Contact details

  • Secretary, Law Society- Tarique Aziz Choudhury (+91 8439048863) Email- tariqueazizc35@gmail.com
  • Joint Secretary, Law Society- Mohammad Asif Iqbal (+91 8537889808)
  • Joint Secretary (Publication), Law Society- Wania Ali (+91 8910424705)
  • Or mail at: – lawsocietyamucm@gmail.com

Disclaimer: All information posted by us on LexPeeps is true to our knowledge. But still it is suggested that you check and confirm things on your level.

WhatsApp Group:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/GRdQLsHRwmB7QVRmS3WK

Telegram:

https://t.me/lexpeeps

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/company/lexpeeps-in-lexpeeps-pvt-ltd

ABSTRACT

The Specific Relief Act 1963 chalks out an array of reliefs that can be sought under the tutelage of the civil courts in addition to the other available civil remedies enshrined under CPC 1908 for aiding the enforcement and due fulfillment of the contractual obligations besides providing a host of other civil reliefs.

INTRODUCTION

The Specific Relief Act was enacted on 13th December 1963 on the recommendations of the 9th report of the law commission and it seeks to effectively replace and widen the scope of the Specific Relief Act 1877. The Act expands the horizon of the civil court by arming it with a greater number of reliefs in addition to the existing reliefs available under civil courts.

The act is not only limited to the remedies for the performance of contracts but also provides relief in a variety of fields. Generally, the branches of substantiative laws lay down the rights and duties as per their purpose and thereby provide for the remedies for the violation of those rights. However, the Specific Relief Act per se does not afford any legal rights, but on the other hand, provides a comprehensive scheme of specific remedies in specific terms for the violation of the legal rights.

It is to be noted that the Specific Relief Act does not provide a remedy for the enforcement of the penal laws but only provides for the enforcement of individual civil rights. The Specific Relief Act broadly provides reliefs under the following heads.

  • Recovery for peaceful possession of the property
  • Specific performance of the contracts
  • Rectification and Cancellation of instruments
  • Recession of Contracts
  • Preventive Relief i.e. Injunction
  • Declaratory Relief
  1. PEACEFUL POSSESSION OF A PROPERTY

Peaceful possession of a property is quite essential for the maintenance of law and order in society since the failure to observe the same has the potential to create disturbance and disequilibrium in society. Civil Laws primarily CPC 1908, do provide relief per se in this matter. The addition of the reliefs under specific relief act further widen the ambit of the relief available to the public and add to their cause and rescue. Henceforth, the first chapter of the said act provides relief to those who have been unlawfully dispossessed of their property which could be both immovable or movable.

Section 5 of the Act deals with the recovery of legal possession of specific immovable property based on the title. The title may be acquired on the basis of either ownership or possession. The one having the better title is entitled to possession of the property. A suit under Section 5 is an ordinary suit under CPC 1908.

Section 6 of the Act provides the remedy of filing a suit if any person is dispossessed of his immovable property without his consent and the due course of law. The plaintiff need not prove better title for the purposes of the suit under this section but has to prove wrongful dispossession.

In Puthukkattil Parangodan v. Parameswaran1, it was held that this section seeks to prevent the violation of law and order by restraining a person from using force to dispossess another of his property without the due course of law.
Section 7 deals with the recovery of possession of specific movable property or money value thereof in alternative through an ordinary suit under CPC 1908. A person is entitled to possession if he has either special (bailment, pawn, etc.) or temporary rights. Under this section, the suit can be brought against the actual owner.

Section 8 deals with the liability of the person in possession of the specific movable property to return it back to the person entitled to immediate possession. Under this section, a suit cannot be brought against the actual owner. Relief under this section is sought for only the return of a specific article and not for monetary compensation unlike section 7.

Ganga Bishan v. Jai Narain2: Relief under this section is claimed when monetary compensation cannot afford necessary relief to the plaintiff for the loss of property or when it is very difficult to ascertain the actual value of the property.

2. SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE OF THE CONTRACTS

Today’s contemporary modern world thrives on the intricacy and nuances of contracts. Due to their utmost significance in the economic hemisphere, contracts can be rightly characterized as modern wealth. They form the base of all economic transactions ranging from all sorts of employments/ professional employments to monetary transactions of the bank. Enforcement of the contracts forms the centerpiece in the execution of the contractual obligations as often a particular contract forms a link in the chain of various interlinked contracts and failure to observe any one of them may lead to serious dysfunction of the economic ecosystem.

The Indian Contracts Act 1872 provides relief to the aggrieved parties for the enforcement of the contracts in the form of damages i.e. monetary compensation only. In some instances, the monetary compensation does not suffice and such circumstances demand actual enforcement of the contract. This is where the specific relief act comes into the picture and provides a speedy and just remedy by demanding the enforcement of the contractual obligations through
the instrument of specific performance of the contracts.

Section 10 of the act states that specific performance of the contracts would be enforced in cases where there is no standard for gauging the damage caused due to non-performance of the contract or where the monetary compensation would not suffice for the loss caused due to nonperformance of the contract3.

  1. RECESSION OF THE CONTRACTS

Voidable contracts are those that are enforceable at the option of one party to the contract but not the other. It remains valid as long as the aggrieved party wishes to continue with the terms of the contract. There are certain factors that may render a contract voidable at the option of the other party. These factors include lack of free consent in the form of undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation, and coercion, under section 19 and 19 (A), failure to perform a time-bound contract in which the time was of the essence under section 55, and when one party to a contract prevents the performance of a reciprocal promise by the other party under section 53. So, the party at whose instance the contract becomes voidable has the right to rescind the contract. Chapter IV of the Specific Relief Act provides relief of the recession of the contracts.

Section 27 and 28 of the Act lay down detailed grounds for filing a suit for recession. A suit for a recession may be brought when the contract is voidable at the instance of the plaintiff or when the contract is unlawful for latent reasons. When the rights over the subject matter of the contract are acquired by any third party in good faith during the course of a contract for a value, implying a change of position of the parties to the contract or when the plaintiff ratified the voidable contract either expressly or impliedly, the court may refuse to rescind the contract.

  1. RECTIFICATION AND CANCELLATION OF INSTRUMENTS

A written transaction is basically called an instrument. The expedience of law and prudence demands a transaction to be in writing. Sometimes, it might so happen that the instruments fail to express the intention of the parties involved due to the operative elements of mutual mistake or fraud. Such a situation demands the rectification of the documents. Section 26 of Chapter III of the Specific Relief act provides for rectification of the mistakenly executed instruments.

When documents/instruments after their due execution are discovered to be void or thereafter become void, such documents need to be canceled and Section 31 to 33 under Chapter V of the Specific Relief Act provides this relief. So basically, when a document becomes void, voidable, or has a reasonable apprehension of causing serious injury to the plaintiff if left outstanding, such instruments can be canceled at the discretion of the court. Benefits are to be restored or compensation is to be given on cancellation of an instrument

In the case of Sri Lakha Granites v. Eklavya Singh4, it has been held that an instrument can be canceled only by a court order under Section 31 of the Specific Relief Act and not by unilateral means.

  1. PREVENTIVE RELIEF I.E. INJUNCTION

Remedy of injunction falls under the ambit of preventive relief. An injunction is a court order that either directs the party concerned to do a particular act (mandatory injunction wherein the court compels the performance of certain acts to prevent a breach of an obligation) or not do a particular act. In such cases, the order of injunction is issued at the instance of the court. Section 36 to 40 under Chapter VII of the Specific Relief act covers the relief of injunction. The objective of injunction is to restrain the commission or continuance of a wrongful act. An injunction is issued against individuals, public bodies, or states and willful disobedience of it results in contempt of court.

These orders are not granted in cases wherein the specific performance of the contract or damages is likely to serve the purpose of the contract, or where damages are appropriate to remedy, or where the plaintiff is not entitled to an injunction on account of his conduct or where an injunction is not the appropriate remedy.

Injunctions are a discretionary relief and may be temporary or perpetual. Temporary injunctions are granted at any stage of suit for a specified period of time and are governed by the provisions of CPC 1908. They are granted for the protection of interest in the property or to prevent a continuous breach of contract. A perpetual injunction can be made only by deciding the merits of the suit via decree and deciding the rights of the parties. It is to be noted that in suits for an injunction, damages may also be claimed additionally.

In Ishwarbhai v. Bhanushali Nanda5, the court observed that the interim injunction can only be sought in the cases where a perpetual injunction is prayed for and not otherwise.

  1. DECLARATORY RELIEF

At times, the person legally entitled to the possession or enjoyment of any immovable property might be denied the right to the enjoyment of such property at the instance of the other. It is in the backdrop of such wrongful denial that the court may issue a general declaration as to the entitlement of such right to the aggrieved party. So if a cloud is cast on the title of any immovable property of the plaintiff, he may dispel it with the aid of this discretionary power of the court and avoid future litigation. Section 34 and 35 under Chapter VI of the Specific Relief Act deal with declaratory relief against the impugned person who denies or is interested in denying the right to the aggrieved party.

Conclusion

The Indian Contracts Act forms the backbone of the contracts law in India. Sometimes, the nature of the contracts demands specific performance. However, the Indian Contracts Act lacks effective means for the enforcement of the contracts and provides remedies for the breach of the contractual obligations in the form of damages only. Further, it lacks means for mandatory enforcement of the contract in the form of injunction orders. The Specific Relief Act strikes to cover the loopholes of the Indian contract act by providing the remedies of specific performance of the contracts, orders of injunction, and recession of instruments.

Besides facilitating the smooth execution of contractual obligations, it seeks to provide a host of other reliefs in the civil sphere through means of rectification and cancellation of instruments, declaratory relief, and orders for peaceful possession of the movable and immovable property. In a nutshell, the Specific Relief Act makes a decent effort to facilitate the cause of the aggrieved parties of the civil sphere of law.

Citations:

  1. AIR 2002 Ker 221
  2. AIR 1983 SC 441
  3. Falcke v. Gray (1859) 4 Drew 651
  4. AIR 2011 Raj 49
  5. AIR 2002 Guj 328

Written by Riya Ganguly student at Bharati Vidyapeeth New Law College, Pune.